Lottâs blogroll

Kevin Baker observes that Lott has removed Baker from his blogroll, presumably because Baker has described Lott as the pro-gun version of Michael Bellesiles.

This fits in with Lott's practice of not linking to criticism, which suggests that he thinks his position is a weak one. Rather than link to crticism and refute it he tries to pretend that it does not exist. Even when he does respond to criticism I make here, he does not link or correctly inform his readers what the source of the criticism is, instead claiming that someone emailed it to him. (For example, see here.)

I have Lott on my blogroll and I link to his statements that I criticize. I want readers to see his side and my side and make up their own minds. To help anyone who wants to see Lott's blog and also the criticism of it, I have written a CGI script that adds permalinks, comments and trackbacks to Lott's blog. You can see the result here.

Tags

More like this

Howard Nemerov has a post defending Lott and responding to Chris Mooney's Mother Jones article. Unfortunately, he gets his facts wrong, leaves out inconvenient facts and indulges in fallacious arguments. I'll go through his post and correct these, but first some general comments. Even…
Last December I examined a posting by John Ray who dismissed ozone depletion as a "Greenie scare" using facts he seemed to have just made up by himself. Now he's back, attacking gun control. This time he's not using facts that he made up---he's using facts that Lott made up. He quotes…
This is an annotated list of John Lott's on line reviews at Amazon and at Barnes and Noble. Most of his reviews were posted anonymously or under a false name, and he used this anonymity to post many five-star reviews of his own books and to pan rival books. When you post a review at…
Lott responds on his blog to Wyeth's accusation that he had no evidence for his claim about Baghdad murders. (My earlier comments are here.) Notice that Lott responds on a minor point, once again ducking the question of the coding errors. And while he links to Wyeth and responds to…

I'm getting the trackback and comment links, but not the permalinks?

Also, just talking hypothetically, what would the CGI script do if past Lott posts got accidentally edited, had the datestamps changed or became lost in a hard drive crash?

Oh, you were expecting visible permalinks? OK, done.
As for the possibility of datestamps changing and disk crashes and stuff, who ever heard of lightning striking twice three n+1 times in the same place?

Have you looked at the amount of time between these two posts by Kevin Baker. It was months. Is this serious? In the first one Kevin Baker claims that he did not like Lott but Lott does nothing for a long time. Aren't you making a big post hoc ergo propter hoc jump in logic? But from what I can tell that is what you see to be doing all the time.