Life imitates the Castle

The Sydney Morning Herald reports

The High Court Computer games enthusiasts are free to modify their Playstations to run cheap games bought overseas or online, following a landmark High Court ruling.

The court found that "mod-chips"- used to override technology that prevents consoles running games not purchased in Australia - are legal.

The decision follows a four-year battle between Eddy Stevens, a Sydney mod-chip supplier based in a backyard at Kensington, and the electronics giant Sony, which claimed the chips were overriding its copyright protection technology.

Kim Weatherall has the serious commentary on the decision
here
and here, but I'm struck by how similar this case is to the plot of The Castle. In the original case in the Federal Court Eddy Stevens represented himself and this was his defence:

Mr Stevens denied that he had supplied and installed chips in PlayStation consoles at any time after March 2001, when s116A had come into force. He acknowledged that he supplied and installed a considerable volume of chips for PlayStation consoles before March 2001, but claimed that any chipping of consoles thereafter was done by his flatmate, whom he reluctantly identified as "Ted".

Fortunately for Eddy Stevens the ACCC stepped in as an amicus curiae with a better argument and he won the case, then lost on an appeal and now has won in the High Court.

Tags

More like this

Eugene Volokh has a post on the subject of amicus briefs that was prompted by the exchange between he, Clayton Cramer and myself over the ACLU. Cramer criticized the ACLU for not filing a brief in a particular case (without ever bothering to answer if he actualy knew they hadn't filed one or just…
I tell ya, sometimes I think you guys think I'm a journalist or a 24 hour news source. I'm not, of course. I'm just a humble blogger, and I do what I can within the constraints of my every day "real life." What? I have a real life? You mean I'm not really a supercomputer who can link with any other…
I was wrong. I know it doesn't happen that often, but I'm forced to admit it. I was wrong. I predicted that Simon Singh would likely lose his appeal against an astonishing illiberal ruling on his libel case by Sir David Eady. Singh, as you may recall, is the British science writer who wrote a now…
A New York state court ruled today that gay couples must be allowed to marry in that state. Like the decision in Massachusetts, this decision is based upon the NY state constitution, not the U.S. Constitution, so it only is enforcable in that state. But it is still an enormously important ruling.…

Oddly enough, I keep my games console in *(wait for it....)* The Pool Room.