Wifi Woo Strikes in Sebastopol

By way of AP and BoingBoing, one can find this post by Dale Daugherty on O'Reilly Radar about the newest attack of the tinfoil-hat-wifi-radiation brigade:

Our town, Sebastopol, had passed a resolution in November to permit a local Internet provider to provide public wireless access. This week, fourteen people showed up at a City Council meeting to make the claim that wireless caused health problems in general and to them specifically. These emotional pleas made the Council rescind its previous resolution.

Ah, California! There's good stuff out there explaining this breed of woo, but these activists still have traction because they're very good at spreading fear and uncertainty. For instance, what do you do as a county supervisor (perhaps with no education in science since college) and a mob shows up at the meeting with signs that say "Just Say No to Radiation"?

Or "Money Talks, We Get CANCER."

Strongly motivated, vocal, organized minority groups can have a powerful effect on politics. And this is irresponsible for several reasons--this anti-antenna movement has grabbed on to health and safety issues to mask their underlying goal: to make the neighborhoods more beautiful by removing antennae!

As such, it is great example of how health and safety concerns and the precautionary principle can be used to simply push other political motivations. Cato and AEI could use this post as footnote 1 in any argument against health and safety legislation.

Tags

More like this

Earlier this year, some in Sebastopol, California were very concerned over potential health hazards of wireless internet and halted a local company from providing public wifi access. (For details, visit O'Reilly). While I'm less nervous over electrical sensitivity, I can't help but wonder what…
Ben Goldacre at Bad Science is leading the way on opposing this new absurdity of "electric smog", and one of it's leading proponents in Britain, Julia Stephenson. It's really too easy. Remember the crank HOWTO? Well, she's just about a perfect example. It all started when she got wifi in her…
One of the fastest growing Christian right legal groups is the Liberty Counsel, run by Matt Staver. This is Jerry Falwell's personal favorite and they've been in the spotlight a lot lately, gaining on the American Center for Law and Justice, the Alliance Defense Fund and the Thomas More Law Center…
If there's one good thing about spending an extra night in Buffalo, without access to a computer and with a rather limited selection of channels on the television, it's that you get a lot of reading done. I managed to plow through all of Edward Humes' book Monkey Girl: Evolution, Education,…

Ah, the legacy of Paul Brodeur. The inability to comprehend the difference between ionizing and non-ionizing radiation is going to be the death of anything radio-related yet...

"Hell no we wont glow"? Have these people been watching old videos from the 50s with "duck and cover"?

What are these people doing outside on a SUNNY day? Do they not know what the sun is doing, up there in the sky, or are they martyring themselves?

Another urban legend here - as with so much on the internet, I cant say if it happens. But its a story I have heard circulating:

A school set up a new wireless network - complete site coverage, an access point every few rooms, all hooked up on a power over ethernet system. Perfect for wireless registration and staff laptops. Within a week staff complaints start coming in - teachers in the rooms with wireless complain of tiredness and headaches. The manager reads all these reports, considers the situation, and patiently explains that the access points have been installed, but not yet plugged in.

I suspect this is very heavily embellished, because I have heard another version in which the transmitter is a mobile phone station in a village - again, people start to fall ill as soon as its installed, and the operator explains that they havn't turned it on yet.