Thanks to spyder for pointing me to this really excellent essay by Michael Berube on academic freedom and the threats to it currently. It's very long but worth the trip.
- Log in to post comments
More like this
I will join the chorus in praising Bérubé's essay on academic freedom. It's excellent; now if only the people most desperately in need of reading it weren't barely literate anti-intellectual thugs, it would be an awesomely persuasive rhetorical tool.
That Mannion fellow explains why the…
I'm a little bit jealous: Seed is well represented at Netroots Nation, but I couldn't swing it this year. It's just as well, as it would have been sandwiched in between a couple of other jaunts, and I'm still trying to get back on my feet after wearing myself out in Atlanta.
It would have been…
Seed's Mr. Space Lee Billings has an interesting piece, The Long Shot:
"If planets are found around Alpha Centauri, it's very clear to me what will happen," Marcy said. "NASA will immediately convene a committee of its most thoughtful space propulsion experts, and they'll attempt to ascertain…
I've been a little too busy to participate, but His Holiness and Eric Weinstein on Twitter have gotten into an interesting exchange about the structure of academia, and the appropriate number of Ph.D.'s in science. As usual, I suspect I'm not fully understanding the majesty of whatever Eric is…
Thanks for the heads-up. It is indeed an excellent essay.
Faculty and instructors shall not infringe the academic freedom and quality of education of their students by persistently introducing controversial matter into the classroom or coursework that has no relation to their subject of study and that serves no legitimate pedagogical purpose.
It reminds me of the old stuff Communists did in my country. It was the same attitude to the faculty: "shut up and deliver your material". Such laws should not be passed.
All I can say in response is that college is not a kind of dinner party. It can indeed be rude to bring up religion or politics at a dinner party, particularly if you are not familiar with all the guests. But at American universities, religion and politics are two of the hundreds of things we discuss on a daily basis. It really is part of our job, evenor especiallyif some of us have unpopular opinions on those subjects.
Hear, hear! If Senator Mumper got his way, I would never have a job.