An Evolutionary/Ecological Model of Cancer Cells

One of the potentially most interesting, yet untapped, area of study in population biology is that of intra-individual variation. One thing we do know, however, is that this variation can contribute to cancers. When cells accumulate mutations, some of these cell lines become cancer cells due to changes to genes involved in regulating the cell cycle. It would be especially interesting to apply the theory from population biology to this somatic variation within individuals.

If any of that stuff sounds interesting, you should check out this paper from Nature Reviews Cancer. The authors summarize applications of evolutionary biology and ecology toward understanding the growth of cancers. See here for a summary. Dan has a good wrap-up on Migrations here.

More like this

I'm slowly working my way1 through my complementary copy of What We Believe but Cannot Prove. I'm almost done -- at page 214 out of 252 -- and I can say that it is very diverse. The essays range from very thoughtful and interesting to way too specific to a particular discipline . . . to off the…
It's been a while since I brought everyone up to date on the progress of my Ecological Development course, because I've been busy. So have the students. After our spring break I subjected them to the dreaded oral exam, which actually isn't so bad. I tried to engage them less in an adversarial role…
For over two centuries, opponents of evolution have searched for examples of natural complexity that could have only been created by design. Reverend William Paley was fond of the eye, with its lens, retina, and other components all beautifully fine-tuned to work with one another. These days, the…
A lot of readers (well, a couple, anyway) have been asking me about the recent article by Peter Duesberg in the most recent issue of Scientific American entitled Chromosomal Chaos and Cancer. I suppose it's because I'm not only a cancer surgeon (which in and of itself is not enough to qualify me to…

It seems to me that this opens up a much more interesting line of inquiry: Anti-cancer drugs from cancers themselves.

Think about it. If individual genetically-distinct cancer cells are competing for limited resources, one thing that may happen is that they will evolve strategies to reduce their opponents' reproductive chances. IANAEB (evol. biol.), nor do I work in any medical field, but I think this sounds like an interesting thing to look for.

By Craig Helfgott (not verified) on 20 Nov 2006 #permalink

Craig,
I'm not sure that's feasible - yes, tumors consist of phenotypically-diverse populations of cells, but any acquired traits that a cell might gain would be accessible to the majority of the other neoplastic cells in the tumor. Certainly some cannibalism amongst cancer cells may occur, but I think that most of the time it's in the form of endocytosis of apoptotic cells, and not predation or production of toxins.

As Hanahan and Weinberg describe in their 2000 Cell review, most cancers are instead characterized by the acquisition of a series of specific traits that allow the success of the dysfunctional cells individually, at the cost of the entire organism. As H&W describe them, they are evasion of apoptosis, self-sufficiency Re:growth signals, insensitivity to anti-growth signals, sustained angiogenesis, limitless reproductive potential, and invasion/metastasis. And this makes sense, I think, because the primary selective force against neoplastic cells is not competing cells, but the elimination and inhibition of such cells by the healthy cells of the body.

It's this predisposition of cells in the early stages of cancer to survive just about everything that we throw at them (even though only 0.1% of cells in a tumor may survive some treatments), that allow the cancer threat to survive dormant for years, only to come back stronger. Just like a highly adaptive microbe, it can evolve and come back regardless of how innovative the therapy - natural selection is smarter than humans.

At least that's my take on cancer progression as an evolving process...