WHO IS SCARING WHO? Case Made By Ohio State Political Scientist That Terrorism Threat is Overblown

i-6c3476aaea433d31d5956bf01f8e2314-binladen_16.jpg

As Inhofe attacks the media for exaggerating the threat of global warming, the GOP continues to pursue its election strategy of making terrorism and the memory of 9/11 the defining criteria for voters come November. John Mueller, political scientist at The Ohio State University, makes a strong case in the latest issue of the journal Foreign Affairs that the terrorism threat has been overblown and exaggerated by the government and the media. Comparing terrorism to global warming makes for an interesting risk assessment exercise.

More like this

If it isn't already obvious, the GOP game plan for the November election is to make September 11 and the war on terror the dominant consideration for voters, rather than the troubles in Iraq, and the lingering questions of GOP competency following Katrina. All the tools of strategic communication…
Yesterday, Senator James Inhofe, Chair of the Committee on Public Works & the Environment, issued a challenge to journalists to stop what he called the "media hype" over global warming. Inhofe compiles a list of what he considers exaggerated distortions of global warming from recent and past…
And by "Prestigious" I mean .... well, see for yourself in this story from Media Matters for America (Reposted with permission): Climate Change Misinformer Of The Year: Marc Morano ClimateDepot.com founder Marc Morano has been called "the Matt Drudge of climate denial," the "king of the skeptics,"…
Via James Hrynyshyn, Nature has a good summary of the state of climate politics in the lead up to Bali. There's even a decent summary of the state of play in Austrlia. Any campaign veteran will tell you that voters are fickle, switching from candidate to candidate and issue to issue as the whim…

Thanks for posting this vital article. Another devastating, empirical attack by John Meuller (and his son, then a professor at the Air War College, Maxwell AFB) on the self-serving neocon doggy "sky is falling" propaganda demonstrated that the number of deaths resulting from the sanctions (comprehensive blockade) on Iraq resulted in more deaths than were produced by the combination of all the standard WMDs in world history. Will be happy to supply the full cite if you wish.

Alas, Homeland Security continues to ratchet up what in the sociological literature is called "a moral crisis" by participating ( and co-sponsoring?) science-light conferences on such lofty topics as "faith based" methods to deal with anxiety arising from terror ("theirs" not ours, of course). A recent instance was on 3/23/10 at Bradley Hills Presbyterian Church, Bethesda, MD. Evidently in an effort to put a benign gloss on this malicious foolishness, the speaker from Homeland Security claimed to be a Menonite pastor. Who knows, perhaps he was what he claimed to be, but it struck me as about as likely as a serving 4-star general keynoting a meeting of the War Resistors League...
I fear that such events constitute the sort of abuse of framing and "expert" dogma or received truth or conventional "wisdom" which renders intelligent discussion of vital issues like global warming more difficult by raising skepticism of all government sponsored speakers and conferences, including legitimate ones which adhere to the highest standards of the scientific method and which meticulously provide the best estimates of levels of uncertainty and which afford audiences adequate opportunity for participation such as q. and a.

Tom

By Tom Nagy, Ph.D. (not verified) on 24 Mar 2010 #permalink