In the 2012 Election, Will The War Room Still be Relevant?

i-170c6e1ff5baff55a23ad44f10b75eda-Newseum_American.jpg

On Monday night, AU's [School of Communication](http://www.american.edu/soc/) sponsored a screening at the Newseum of the 1992 campaign documentary *The War Room* with a panel discussion that included stars George Stephanopoulos, Dee Dee Myers and Paul Begala. The event was part of the [Reel Journalism film series](http://www.newseum.org/events_edu/reel_journalism/) co-sponsored by the School of Communication and the Newseum. The series is hosted by Nick Clooney, veteran broadcast journalist and father of actor George Clooney. The Politico [covered the event](http://www.politico.com/news/stories/0509/22729.html) and runs this photo of the discussion.

One question from the audience struck me as particularly important and it was prompted by a line of conversation that had developed early on during the evening event. The panelists after viewing the film had remarked that it looked very old and very dated, everything from the clothes and the hair to the technology. Stephanopoulos even joked that he was a bit embarrassed by the film since he thought their "war room" in comparison to the 2008 Obama campaign was relatively amateurish and unsophisticated. Everything they were trying to do, remarked Stephanopoulos, was completely new and the Obama campaign took any innovations they had introduced in 1992 to a dramatically different and altered level.

So given this discussion, the audience member asked whether in 2012--twenty years after the film had been made--if there was anything of relevance to be learned if students or young campaign staffers were to watch the film?

If I remember correctly, it was Dee Dee Myers who stepped in with remarks that reflected how I would have answered the question. She correctly observed that if there was an enduring lesson to *The War Room*, it was the importance of understanding how voters think, creating a message in line with that thinking, and then successfully and consistently delivering that message.

When I teach my [course](http://scienceblogs.com/framing-science/2008/01/my_political_communicat…) on Political Communication and my seminars on communication theory, I often show clips from *The War Room* as well as the more recent 2004 campaign film [*So Goes the Nation*](http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DAfzvep-HMc). Indeed, when I show these clips, I use them as a way to bring home and directly visualize for students the importance of framing, messaging, and what political scientist Samuel Popkin refers to as the "[low information rationality](http://scienceblogs.com/framing-science/2008/07/the_washington_post_on_…)" of audiences.

In fact, James Carville, Clinton's 1992 campaign director and the co-star with Stephanopoulos of the *War Room*, has credited Popkin's book *The Reasoning Voter* for helping to inform his message strategy on behalf of Clinton. Famously, Carville's war room headquarters featured on a white board the three themes that every message in the campaign was intended to be crafted around, themes and talking points that resonated with the concerns of key swing voters in 1992:

Change versus more of the same

It's the Economy, Stupid!

And don't forget about health care.

As Stephanopoulos remarked early on in Monday's panel at the Newseum, these themes were the guide posts for the campaign. If something was not translatable or relevant to these three over-arching frames to the campaign, then it probably wasn't worth talking about or spending communication resources on.

You can watch video of [Stephanopoulos' remarks](http://www.newseum.org/events_edu/event_archive/reporting.aspx?item=vid…) on this angle at the Newseum web site as well as full video or other excerpts of the panel discussion.

More like this

As some here know, I have a daughter. If some idiot (like, for example, Laura Ingraham) made a comment about her, I'd stand up for her. That's what fathers do - especially if that comment had something to do about your daughter's body. Apparently this is not the case with John McCain. Quoting…
"New Evangelical" Joel Hunter (blue shirt) works with church members on a recycling campaign. Evangelical leader Joel C. Hunter, a registered Republican, will give the closing prayer at the Democratic National Convention on Thursday, joining Al Gore and nominee Barack Obama on stage in front of 70,…
As I like to say, when it comes to science debates, the public is far more likely to be miserly in reaching a judgment than fully informed. Most citizens are cognitive misers relying heavily on information short cuts and heuristics to make up their minds about a science controversy, often in the…
It's supposed to be rainy, so why not attend? Carl Zimmer will be there. MAS does really cool outreachy things like teacher training so they're worth supporting, even if you can't attend. Anyway, this found its way into my email machine: Join the Massachusetts Academy of Sciences as we spend a…