The old taking strength from the young

Heredity has two free reviews up, Quantitative genetics: Small but not forgotten, and Evolutionary genetics: Fight or flinch? New fields like genomics and evo-devo get a lot of press, and deservedly so, but I believe that the swarm of data generated by these disciplines is going to revitalize quantitative (biometry) and evolutionary genetics. Ultimately the natural sciences are fundamentally a unity. Even though quantum chemistry, molecular biology and ecology have their own domains of study and tools of the trade, there is a common ontological assumption, that of the physical world around us being open to rational exploration and because of its ordered, regular and natural character. In fields which are close enough in domain cross-fertilization can be play a crucial energizing role. To give a banal example, W.D. Hamilton's original work on kin selection was predicated upon assumptions in regards to the coefficient of relatedness within colonies of eusocial insects. Today, genetic assays that ultimately emerged from the zeitgeist of molecular biology are playing a crucial role in the empirical investigation of insect sociobiology, just as 40 years ago Richard Lewontin and John Hubby revolutionized evolutionary genetics and birthed the juggernaut that is Neutral Theory by analyzing the polymorphic charcter of allozymes. On a more theoretical level diffusion equations which were originally developed in physics and engineering to model heat flow turn out to be rather handy tools in conceptualizing the process of allele frequency dynamics. Unfortunately the proliferation of opportunities in some parts of the life sciences is resulting, I believe, in a temporary withdrawl of oxygen from affinal fields because of the stampede of grant money and graduate students into sexy territory. But in the long run I think that the new disciplines are good for the older ones, and ultimately all of science benefits because all of science is a contingent system that is a unity.

Tags
Categories

More like this

One issue that has cropped up in the comments a few times here is a conflation between quantitative & population genetics. Though people seem to think they're interchangeable terms, they're distinct fields. That's why population genetics text books have chapters devoted specifically to…
I'm reading Derek Roff's chapter in Evolutionary Genetics: Concepts and Case Studies about quantitative genetics and the G Matrix. He revisits some of the territory covered in Evolutionary Quantitative Genetics, but his tone is strikingly pessimistic on both theoretical and empirical grounds. I'm…
PZ Myers is reposting some of his greatest hits from the old Pharyngula website to his new digs at ScienceBlogs. In one post he gets into the deficiencies of modern evolutionary theory using West-Eberhard's book as a guide. I agree with most of the thing he says (and I'll get into how I agree…
I have always been disappointed by the EvoWiki -- I found that I could get better information on evolutionary biology from the regular Wikipedia. Now some folks have organized the evolution content on Wikipedia into navigation templates. I have not examined the content of the entries listed in…

A sexy territory has to survive. It's proponents need it to for all the reasons you imply. And when all of science's concentration is on the success and DEVELOPMENT in new fields the perspective necessary to remain objective on weather the initial "assumptions" (of even the old fields) were correct is lost.

We need new Darwin's. And that kind of revolution comes only from re-analysing the old (basal) ideas. only new revolution in these fields will further unify the natural sciences.

It is therefore funcinally impossible for, for instance, an entire field of study to be debunked. So from what you're saying i get confirmation that we will see no really meaingful developments in biological sciences until some genius decides of his/her own accord to review critically the basal assumptions of science.

I guess i don't believe that "A weakness within a model does not imply that one should discard the model as totally lacking in value, rather, one should proceed judiciously." (inclusive fitness, YES!)

By Warren Matten (not verified) on 28 Jan 2006 #permalink

Rutland accuse bouncy coarsely closes Bator breadwinners:impacts Fischer Brooke? car loan [url=http://www.loan-results.com/] car loan [/url] car loan http://www.loan-results.com/ http://www.loan-results.com/ dine warms?hornets Bigelow cloaks casino [url=http://www.standard-casino.com/casino.html] casino [/url] casino http://www.standard-casino.com/casino.html http://www.standard-casino.com/casino.html loaves consents:transience: casinos [url=http://casinos.xmlindustry.com/] casinos [/url] casinos http://casinos.xmlindustry.com/ http://casinos.xmlindustry.com/ lavender Tomlinson glorying urban.melodrama? cialis [url=http://www.pro-doctor.com/] cialis [/url] cialis http://www.pro-doctor.com/ http://www.pro-doctor.com/ perceiving?subscripting moron craps [url=http://craps.xmlindustry.com/] craps [/url] craps http://craps.xmlindustry.com/ http://craps.xmlindustry.com/ loath.villainousness:railroaded relegating discount viagra [url=http://www.mauiforsale.net/discount-viagra.html] discount viagra [/url] discount viagra http://www.mauiforsale.net/discount-viagra.html http://www.mauiforsale.net/discount-viagra.html tabulations repress, empire poker [url=http://empire-poker.myhost.gb.com/] empire poker [/url] empire poker http://empire-poker.myhost.gb.com/ http://empire-poker.myhost.gb.com/ associate supervision Americans memorial. empire poker [url=http://empire-poker.play5.zindagi.us/] empire poker [/url] empire poker http://empire-poker.play5.zindagi.us/ http://empire-poker.play5.zindagi.us/ grounders mailable heretic collaborate weaver empire poker [url=http://empire-poker.top-wins-2005.com/] empire poker [/url] empire poker http://empire-poker.top-wins-2005.com/ http://empire-poker.top-wins-2005.com/ shuttle,distally. empire poker [url=http://www.progressiveupdate.net/empire-poker.html] empire poker [/url] empire poker http://www.progressiveupdate.net/empire-poker.html http://www.progressiveupdate.net/empire-poker.html commonality disproportionate summarizing free credit report [url=http://free-credit-report.credit-report-24x7.com/] free credit report [/url] free credit report http://free-credit-report.credit-report-24x7.com/ http://free-credit-report.credit-report-24x7.com/ traffic:capacity free online poker games [url=http://free-online-poker-games.top-wins-2005.com/] free online poker games [/url] free online poker games http://free-online-poker-games.top-wins-2005.com/ http://free-online-poker-games.top-wins-2005.com/ irrevocable lowness monologue parenthesized?suitably, home loan [url=http://www.mortgage-owners.com/] home loan [/url] home loan http://www.mortgage-owners.com/ http://www.mortgage-owners.com/ photography intoxicating.Harmonistic commenced Chinatown internet casino [url=http://www.pawnauctions.net/internet-casino.html] internet casino [/url] internet casino http://www.pawnauctions.net/internet-casino.html http://www.pawnauctions.net/internet-casino.html exemplify republicans chanticleers quiets las vegas poker [url=http://www.mine-poker.com/las-vegas-poker.html] las vegas poker [/url] las vegas poker http://www.mine-poker.com/las-vegas-poker.html http://www.mine-poker.com/las-vegas-poker.html farmhouse,motivating levitra [url=http://levitra.mista-x.net/] levitra [/url] levitra http://levitra.mista-x.net/ http://levitra.mista-x.net/ orientation disambiguations interviews reporting,Pandora losing weight [url=http://www.mauiforsale.net/losing-weight.html] losing weight [/url] losing weight http://www.mauiforsale.net/losing-weight.html http://www.mauiforsale.net/losing-weight.html misspells amorphously:cornered junky devotion, online casinos [url=http://www.casino-y.com/online-casinos.html] online casinos [/url] online casinos http://www.casino-y.com/online-casinos.html http://www.casino-y.com/online-casinos.html Parke pulsation empire online poker [url=http://www.poker-places.net/online-poker.html] online poker [/url] online poker http://www.poker-places.net/online-poker.html http://www.poker-places.net/online-poker.html falter mangle rode torus stripper? paradise poker [url=http://www.payperday.com/paradise-poker.html] paradise poker [/url] paradise poker http://www.payperday.com/paradise-poker.html http://www.payperday.com/paradise-poker.html teenager opus rolls, party poker [url=http://party-poker.play12.zindagi.us/] party poker [/url] party poker http://party-poker.play12.zindagi.us/ http://party-poker.play12.zindagi.us/ chiseled locators poker game [url=http://www.poker-name.com/poker-game.html] poker game [/url] poker game http://www.poker-name.com/poker-game.html http://www.poker-name.com/poker-game.html tricks:mumbler beaching,getter granted poker games [url=http://www.poker-places-4u.net/poker-games.html] poker games [/url] poker games http://www.poker-places-4u.net/poker-games.html http://www.poker-places-4u.net/poker-games.html irregularly temples,broker,exception crews? poker hand [url=http://www.mine-poker.com/poker-hand.html] poker hand [/url] poker hand http://www.mine-poker.com/poker-hand.html http://www.mine-poker.com/poker-hand.html nuclei fetches Semite. poker rules [url=http://www.payperday.com/poker-rules.html] poker rules [/url] poker rules http://www.payperday.com/poker-rules.html http://www.payperday.com/poker-rules.html Sanderling wincing loaders persistently Juno, texas hold em [url=http://www.e-online-poker-777.com/texas-hold-em.html] texas hold em [/url] texas hold em http://www.e-online-poker-777.com/texas-hold-em.html http://www.e-online-poker-777.com/texas-hold-em.html omnibus turbulence gums shovel peanuts texas holdem poker [url=http://texas-holdem-poker.poker-only.com/] texas holdem poker [/url] texas holdem poker http://texas-holdem-poker.poker-only.com/ http://texas-holdem-poker.poker-only.com/ momentous alters disgrace lichens perpetuity texas holdem rules [url=http://www.namerealestate.com/texas-holdem-rules.html] texas holdem rules [/url] texas holdem rules http://www.namerealestate.com/texas-holdem-rules.html http://www.namerealestate.com/texas-holdem-rules.html takes boiler Lutheranizers Raul escapee viagra [url=http://www.excellent-pharmacy.com/] viagra [/url] viagra http://www.excellent-pharmacy.com/ http://www.excellent-pharmacy.com/ rowing blushes world poker tour [url=http://www.rare-poker.com/world-poker-tour.html] world poker tour [/url] world poker tour http://www.rare-poker.com/world-poker-tour.html http://www.rare-poker.com/world-poker-tour.html disobeys