New survey of American religion

Baylor university has a new survey (PDF) of American religion out, and it is an excellent supplement to The American Religious Identification Survey.

Here are some findings I found interesting:

  • Instead of 14% of Americans with "No religion" (nearly doubling in a generation) the new survey suggests that a more accurate number is 10.8% (still an increase). The issue here is that the set of individuals who a) attend religious services b) disavows any affiliation has increased greatly over the past generation. The number of young people (18-30) with "No religion" is greater than the median.
  • About 5% of Americans seem to be atheists, around 40% of those who are not religiously affiliated. 8% of Jews are atheists. None of the black respondents in their survey were atheists.
  • Secularism and theological liberalism are positively correlated with income and education.
  • 40% of Americans believe in Atlantis.
  • Women and blacks seem more inclined to believe they are sinners in the hands of an angry God than whites or males.

Two points. These data relate to two of my recent posts, first, religious belief is natural. Today we tend to associate supernatural beliefs with structured institutional organizations with creeds and rituals. But as these institutions weaken due to cultural freelancing we will see a rise in the number of those who disavow organized religion and yet are still passionately committed to God(s). The survey in fact shows that belief in "paranormal" phenomena drops with Biblical literalism, which suggests that as creedal constraints are released other supernatural beliefs tend to fill their vacuum. Second, the I also hold that institutions as a whole are becoming less powerful in shaping our cultural sensibilities, so this is likely not a decline in religion, as much as the decline of institutions which scaffold and systematize religious passions.

On a related note, spirituality and religiosity seem to be separable psychological predispositions.

Tags

More like this

I've received a few emails from friends about this piece in Edge titled Why the Gods are Not Winning. The reason is that I've made it clear that in many ways I think religiosity as we understand it naturally arises out of the intersection of our societies and our cognition, that atheism is not the…
Reviewing Elaine Howard Ecklund's Science vs. Religion for the Washington Post last May, I noted: Rice University sociologist Elaine Ecklund offers a fresh perspective on this debate in "Science vs. Religion." Rather than offering another polemic, she builds on a detailed survey of almost 1,700…
Pew has an excellent survey up about the state of religion and religiosity in China. There isn't a lot of good data out of China on this topic for obvious reasons. One of the phenomenon of recent years in the West has been the perception among evangelicals that China is the scene of mass…
Data from The American Religious Identification Survey is floating around the blogosphere right now. One of the points noted is that the number of Americans who avow "No Religon" has gone from 8.2% to 14.1% of the American population between 1990 and 2001. Now, one meme floating around is…

Ew. From the report: belief in alternative medicine: 74.5%, Telekinesis: 28%.

Yes, delusion must be natural.

Careful about the Atlantis data. The wording was "Ancient advanced civilizations, such as Atlantis, once existed". I can find a number of ways to understand that claim so as to make it true. It all depends on what "advanced" means, and to what degree you understand "such as" as a qualifier.

Some might suggest that football is a religion because it has rituals and a cult like society of followers. I doubt people that say they have no religion have thought of that. My hunch is that everyone is involved in some kind of religion. A proper definition of religion is needed.