An atheist in the Catholic Church

In my post below I wanted to emphasize that religion has several distinct and independent dimensions. Too often in our modern era religion is reduced purely to the dimension of confession or belief because of its relative accessibility to outsiders. Here is some of that complexity on display, from page 371 of The Pursuit of Glory: Europe 1648-1815:

Less comical but more dangerous was a prelate like Etienne-Charles Lomenie de Brienne, whose composition of a materialist treatise at the Sorbonne in 1751 did not prevent him entering the priesthood and becoming Vicar-General of Rouen the following year at the age of twenty-five. He subsequently became Bishop of Condom in 1760 and Archbishopof Toulouse in 1762. Proposed for the archbishopric of Paris, he was turned down by Louise XVI on the grounds that 'at least the Archbishop of Paris must believe in God'. This check did not prevent him becoming first minister in 1787, Archbishop of Sens...and acquiring the cardinal's hat. After the outbreak of the Revolution, he showed his gratitude by voting for the Civil Consitution of the Clergy and buying - and then desecrating - the confiscated abbey of St-Pierre-le-Vif....

There was once a time when Europe was the Faith and the Faith was Europe. To some extent this did enforce a greater degree of outward belief, but at the extremes there were likely individuals would could never suffer a religious outlook. With the involvement of the Roman Catholic Church in secular affairs it is no surprise that unbelievers used it as an institutional ladder from which they derived instrumental benefit.

Tags

More like this

I'm getting into an exchange with Luis below about the rise of European domination. Unfortunately with historical questions I can't "prove" my case as in mathematics, nor can I cite an empirical result that is extremely generalizable as in much of the natural sciences. I'm trying to describe a…
A FORMER vicar-general in the archdiocese of Munich has claimed that he was pressurised last month into taking the blame for a mistake made 30 years ago by the then Archbishop of Munich, Joseph Ratzinger (now Pope Benedict), concerning the case of a paedophile priest. Fr Gerhard Gruber has now said…
Arnold Kling highlights this section from a Scientific American article, The Science of Economic Bubbles and Busts: But behavioral economics experiments routinely show that despite similar outcomes, people (and other primates) hate a loss more than they desire a gain, an evolutionary hand-me-down…
When Christopher Hitchens writes about religion, he is always reliable. Over at Slate he offers his thoughts on the Pope's recent dust-up with the Muslim community: Attempting to revive his moribund church on a visit to Germany, where the Roman congregations are increasingly sparse, Joseph…

Holw cow, dude.

Bishop of Condom? I dig that, it's like a nickname for a porn star with a special concern for STD protection.

From Wikipedia article on Condom, France:

Given the more widespread social use, in the English language, of the word condom, it is interesting to note that the town is located on the river Baïse; baise, without the diaeresis, is a French vulgarism for a sex act. In French language however, a condom is usually called préservatif and seldom condom. The city is a popular target for street sign stealing tourists. It is also home to a museum of famous population-control devices.

"The Christian religion is a human invention like the faith of the Jews and the Arabs"--Benedetto Caetani, Pope Boniface VIII