Atheists and apostates: similarities and differences

A personal experience of mine is that many apostates from religion have...issues. On the other hand, people who were raised, or always were, atheists tend to mostly be almost confused by religion. But I was curious as to possible differences between these two groups, and those believe in God, or were unbelievers and now believed in God. So I decided to check the GSS. Here's the bottom line for the GODCHNG variable:

64 DON'T BELIEVE NOW, NEVER HAVE
116 DON'T BELIEVE NOW, USED TO
174 BELIEVE NOW, DIDN'T USED TO
2,610 BELIEVE NOW, ALWAYS HAVE

In the tables below you read from left to right, those who are atheists, always were, to those who are atheists, weren't always, those who are theists, weren't always, and those who are theists and were always. Two points

1) I'm surprised at how step-wise some of the trends are. Look at the proportions for sex for example.

2) There are some data which suggest that those who leave religion experience stressed relationships with their family. See the data for time spent with family.

i-c921b7c723e38717db6476418e36d964-alcoholbelief.jpg

i-2ec24261365c608fc5e47a7cea65f9a2-armedbeliefs.jpg

i-68c8bed1c1f23295d4f5a80b63749b81-degreebeliefs.jpg

i-3f614e77d5347f429889336f247d4810-divorcebelief.jpg

i-98551456b33bb38e1e0c638147d1ecb5-eveningbelief.jpg

i-8dbd9b2c8ddc30479fdd0a587c751d64-laborbelief.jpg

i-a2f0431c71c6f73eac1ff7ee60909f76-partybelief.jpg

i-7adf5b69a75a8418b7c5bc538f8e4089-politicsbelief.jpg

i-fa39b66cb54c5e4a433db27241738780-racebelief.jpg

i-5228d919405abe6ff0783a4600867d73-regionbelief.jpg

i-e667f656ffefe3662e3182e297b557e9-sexbelief.jpg

i-b7fc1c14e8716989fc31058188530bda-spouserelbelief.jpg

i-c2079f1626dac11d5ec3ee386a80db08-wordsumbelief.jpg

Tags

More like this

I'm an atheist. Just like some people who are Christians but weren't always tell me that they "always believed in Christ," myself, I've never believed in God. Before the age of 7 I did avow a belief in God, but in hindsight I see only the most minimal of deisms in my conception of the world aside…
John Hawks points me to a "He said, she said," piece which wonders whether there is an inverse relationship between belief in the paranormal and religion. The basic thesis is that the mind abhors a vacuum so without institutionally guided supernatural beliefs people simply revert to "default"…
Does religion increase "virtuous" behavior? So far the research on the topic has been inconclusive. A big problem with most studies is that they tend to be correlational. For example, religious people are more likely to say they are willing to help others. But are they willing to help others…
Huffington Post has a short article up about the phenomenon of Jews who don't believe in God. Turns out there are a lot of us: Atheism is entrenched in American Judaism. In researching their book American Grace, authors Robert Putnam and David Campbell found that half of all American Jews doubt…

I find the more remarkable graph by far the last one.

Fascinating.

My guess is that the underlying factor is the positive association between IQ and atheism.

High IQ kids in modern cultures seem often to become spontaneously atheist aged about 6-8 - unless otherwise socialized. This is not currently explained.

I am unsure whether atheism is an advantage or a disadvantage on average - and the answer would probably be different for different levels of analysis and different religions.

Probably atheism is maladaptive (in a biological sense - i.e. fitness reducing, fertility lowering) maybe because atheism supports more effective pursuit of individual happiness. I understand that most surveys suggest that atheists seem to be more selfish/ less altruistic then Christians (in the USA).

Some (not yet published) research makes clear that atheists differ from religious people in terms of Simon Baron Cohen's personality dimensions of empathizing and systemizing - atheists being less empathizing and more systemizing. Presumably these personality traits would be substantially heritable.

Interesting how the spouses of most atheists belong to some religion. Non-believers are so rare, it's difficult to find their own to marry. I imagine this kind of coupling causes some friction. As an atheist, I was always tolerant of my girlfriends' beliefs, but my skepticism didn't always sit well with them. (And no, I didn't have these girlfriends at the same time.)

Hey! What about us agnostics: always agnostic; was agnostic, now believer; was believer, now agnostic.

I think the second graph is interesting. So much for that "no atheists in foxholes" BS. Even when I was officially a believer, I couldn't understand that. How could anyone be out there in the living hell of a battlefield and believe there was a loving god in all this? Reflexively saying a prayer when the bullets and grenades are flying all over the place, or taking communion before the battle starts, doesn't consitute belief. For a lot of people, it's mainly old habit and/or a comfort ritual.

I'm also suspicious of the family relationships correlation. Some of us don't spend much time with our families because we're too far away. One of my brothers lives on the opposite coast, and I'm 300 miles away from our parents, so we can't afford to visit more than once or twice a year. (We email back and forth pretty often.) My other two sibs live within a few miles of the rest of the family and are in and out of each other's houses all the time.

As for the friction between believer/nonbeliever family members: I'm a Preacher's Kid, albeit from a progressive/liberal background, and I'm not sure my parents know I'm an agnostic. I don't talk about it, no big deal. My parents and I share political and social values although I'm quite a bit more liberal than they are.

My sister and one of my brothers are still at least nominally mainline Christian and have raised their children in a Christian environment but aren't church members currently. The only relationship that might be described as somewhat strained is with my other brother, who became a hardcore Fundamentalist.

By themadlolscien… (not verified) on 20 Aug 2008 #permalink

humans love music, meditation and community. religion provides that. it's just that the premise is all fooked up.

By genesgalore (not verified) on 21 Aug 2008 #permalink