Whither the cloud?

New Nail in Google Cloud Coffin:

Here's what Google fears: If its cloud-computing system crashes, or inadvertently lets companies view their rivals' confidential documents all over the world, the entire system of cloud-based business-information processing collapses. Companies' most precious secrets are leaked, as are government files; suddenly, your tax history is available for anyone to read. The world's governments and businesses panic and come fleeing back to software that is embedded in individual computers, but not before incalculable damage is done to the modern economy and the privacy rights of ordinary citizens.

Lately, the latter scenario's been getting a little more likely. Last year, Gmail crashed three times, and Google Docs, the service that migrates word-processing and spreadsheet documents onto the cloud, crashed in July. In February, the company's gmail froze for several hours, right in the middle of the business day in Europe. Earlier this month, a small percentage of word-processing documents were made available to people who shouldn't have access to them. If people can't guarantee that their private documents will stay private, they may never join the cloud utopia.

"Too Big To Fail" anyone? When it comes to something like gaming I can envisage consoles disappearing. You might get angry if your cable service goes down, but it isn't "mission critical." If Google Docs becomes ubiquitous in the office it seems like it is very amenable to the Black Swan criticism.


More like this

For now. When it comes down to it, benevolent dictatorship resting on a perfectly anarchistic base is the only way to go. Democracy is too easily bought. Free Market Forces do not make everything all nice and efficient and stuff. Wherever information can be OpenSource and OpenAccess it should be…
In general, I try to keep the content of this blog away from my work. I don't do that because it would get me in trouble, but rather because I spend enough time on work, and blogging is my hobby. But sometimes there's an overlap. One thing that's come up in a lot of conversations and a lot of…
In part I, I wrote about my first semester of teaching on-line and talked about our challenges with technology. Blackboard had a database corruption event during finals week and I had all kinds of struggles with the Windows version of Microsoft Excel. Mike wrote and asked if I thought students…
Critics Say Google Invades Privacy With New Service: When Google introduced Buzz -- its answer to Facebook and Twitter -- it hoped to get the service off to a fast start. New users of Buzz, which was added to Gmail on Tuesday, found themselves with a ready-made network of friends automatically…

You're familiar with spam, right? Much of that comes from compromised Windows PCs in ordinary people's homes. Spam is thus a good illustration of one aspect of the Internet that gets overlooked too much: everyone can have their own server on the Internet. Indeed, I have several. And I still don't fully understand the obsession with GMail and all things Googly.

By Matthew Platte (not verified) on 26 Mar 2009 #permalink

The company I work for is quite leery of outsourcing data. Some machines exist on subcontractor's sites, but the corporate IT maintains full control over them.

Crashes, attacks, subversion... all these are very real risks.

The department I work for has a research data cloud where all the labs can offsource their data. The server farm, from what I understand, is in house and has physical tape backups. Data is too expensive to make to lose.

There are good reasons to use "cloud computer" (man I hate that name - what happened to client-server?) However relying wholly on it can be a disaster (IMO). I think being able to work offline is a huge benefit.

There are good reasons to use "cloud computer" (man I hate that name - what happened to client-server?) However relying wholly on it can be a disaster (IMO). I think being able to work offline is a huge benefit.

yeah. it seems that even laptops (e.g., netbooks) are now so cheap that you can have it both ways.