The secularizing & de-Catholicizing 1990s

Gallup has a new report up, This Easter, Smaller Percentage of Americans Are Christian, which is rather self-explanatory. These data aren't surprising, other surveys report the same general finding. Here's an interesting chart with some long term trends:


I want to point to the numbers for Catholicism. In the early 1990s I remember reading popular press accounts about how Catholicism would become the dominant religion of the United States in the early decades of the 20th century because of immigration. That doesn't seem like it's panning out. Why? The American Religious Identification Survey reports massive defection from Catholicism among younger Latinos, while the Religious Landscape Survey highlights Catholic problems with retention of those who were raised Catholic. Obviously the projections based on what we knew in 1990 had some faulty assumptions. Something to keep in mind when we make straight line extrapolations.

Another trend in the 1990s was the massive disaffiliation from organized religion, as evidenced by this chart:


I want to emphasize that most of these people are not atheists or agnostics. Most data (e.g., check the General Social Survey or Religious Landscape Survey) imply that only around 1/3 of people with "No religion" are atheists or agnostics. That being said, it is clear that after a period of secularization in the 1970s in the wake of the cultural upheaval of the 1960s, the trends for religious affiliation stabilized in the 1980s. If you read some of the scholarly literature there is an assumption that the 1970s was sui generis insofar as it was simply the defection of those who were nominal believers to begin with. The stabilization of the 1980s was assumed to be a new stable state that would persist indefinitely. As it happens that was not so, as the 1990s was a second period of massive secularization. Massive in that those with "No religion" jumped as a proportion of the population on the order of 50-100% (depending on survey & methodology). In fact, if "No religion" was its own religious category it would be the fastest growing religion in the United States (at least if you put an appropriate cut-off in terms of initial numbers).

Of course you didn't read this in the media. Unlike revivals or mass conversions, the consistent dynamic of defection is relatively imperceptible. Rather than documenting the massive wave of secularization, the media reported on the religious revival occurring among the evangelicals. And though it is true that evangelicals are a larger and larger proportion of American Christians, that is a slice of the pie which is shrinking!

Does this mean that the teens will continue the process of secularization? I wouldn't bet on anything....

More like this

I remember back in the early 1990s that there was some talk about the United States going from a plural majority Protestant nations, to a Roman Catholic one at some point in the early 21st century. This in itself wouldn't be that big of a deal today, Canada already has more Catholics than…
The Inductivist had a post up bemoaning the cultural liberalism and secularity of today's youth at the same time that I suggested that the culture wars will continue. My reasoning was that polarization still exists, and in fact is greater among the youth than the older cohorts. On the other hand…
Over at Why Evolution Is True Greg Mayer wonders: I also recalled that the percentage of religiously unaffiliated had gone up noticeably from 1990 to 2008, and that another survey found the percentage was higher among young people. What could have happened so that younger people, growing up in the…
This whole conversion story in Afghanistan has been in the news recently. The Christian Science Monitor attempts to put the issue of conversion from Islam to another religion in an international perspective. I am cautious about making large generalizations without qualifications, but I will…

I don't see where Catholic identification has dropped so much from 1985 until now. It's still within most error margins.

During the "long 1960s" (1965-72), I see a drastic and permanent drop-off from 70 to 60; and in the late 1970s, another but milder step down from 60 to the high 50s.

I don't see where Catholic identification has dropped so much from 1985 until now. It's still within most error margins.

there are other data. e.g., american religious identification survey showed a decline from 26 to 24.5% of the adult population between 1990 and 2001. they're survey size was way larger than gallup.

I was somewhat surprised to discover that the Catholic population of my state has doubled in the past decade from 4% to 8% of the population. Over 50% of Catholics in our state are now Hispanic. I recently attended Catholic holy week services in Spanish at a Catholic Church that has added two Sunday services in Spanish to accomodate the influx of Hispanic Catholics in the area.

I've also read that many, if not most, Hispanic Catholics are unregistered, so accurate numbers are not available.

God bless...

I do wonder how the Catholic church keeps getting priests.