1. gnxp
  2. Going for the pain of paying

Going for the pain of paying

By razib on October 8, 2009.

For Gun-Shy Consumers, Debit Is Replacing Credit:

Visa announced this spring that spending on Visa debit cards in the United States surpassed credit for the first time in the company's history. In 2008, debit payment volume was $206 billion, compared with credit volume of $203 billion. MasterCard reported that for the first six months of this year, the volume of purchases on its debit cards increased 4.1 percent, to $160 billion, in the United States. Spending on credit and charge cards sank 14.8 percent, to $233 billion.

"Consumers are rational thinking individuals, and they're going to shift their behavior in a way that fits with their current economic situation," said Scott Strumello, an associate with the Auriemma Consulting Group, a Long Island-based payment card advisory firm. "They're thinking more seriously about it, and many may decide, 'I'm going to use debit where I can and reserve credit for larger purchases.' "

I think really what's going on here is that people are embracing the pain of paying; when you decouple time of payment from what you're purchasing that tends to result in more purchase than would otherwise be the case. A perfectly rational individual wouldn't need to make a distinction between debit and credit, what does it matter if you pay for a latte tomorrow (that is, it comes out of your account tomorrow) vs. the next billing cycle? No, people are rational about the fact that they are irrational. Pay later = buy more, pay tomorrow = buy less. If you want to buy less then heighten the immediacy of the cost.

Tags
Cognitive Science
Culture
economics
Psychology
Rationality
economics

More like this

Credit Cards and the Brain
David Brooks' column today is filled with some depressing financial facts: Between 1989 and 2001, credit-card debt nearly tripled, soaring from $238 billion to $692 billion. By last year, it was up to $937 billion, the report said. State governments aggressively hawk their lottery products, which…
How Much Should Money Cost? (And Whom Should You Pay?)
It's an odd-sounding question, but, if you use a debit card, a very important one. I bring this up as The Huffington Post recently published an article about the political battle over the fees banks charge stores when customers use their credit and debit cards. While the article--and much of the…
It Can Be Expensive to Use Money If...
...you're poor. Previously, I discussed the effects of the de facto privatization of money: But most of the discussion is over how large the fees should be. That's important, but ignores the larger issue: the de facto privatization of our monetary system. While it doesn't seem obvious, when you…
Credit
Tyler Cowen weighs in on the latest twist in the bailout plan, which involves funneling money to credit card companies. Tyler asks if the Feds should really be in the business of encouraging more credit card borrowing. (I've actually been enjoying getting fewer credit card offers in the mail.) His…

I got a debit card because I wanted to be able to access my ATM rather than asking the bank people for a withdrawal. Never bothered to get a credit hard. I received offers in the mail when I was in college, but I didn't see the point when I didn't have a job. I guess I'm being irrational in that if I used a credit card I'd get some rewards for spending (apparently financed by retailers who pay the credit card companies to drum up more spending), but I also should have started contributing to my 401K a long time ago.