Creation

i-8f1be6c0b562019ce867f8355ec0d843-conely.pngI went and saw Creation today. I enjoyed the film, though personally I am a bit tired of the religion vs. science angle. To some extent I felt that there was a conflation between the views & emphases of Thomas Huxley and Charles Darwin. Paul Bettany's character seemed to be expositing a view of evolution which was less subtle than what the real Darwin outlined so as to juxtapose his own stance cleanly against the simple narrative offered by traditional religion.

But a movie is a story about characters, not a perfect reenactment of history. One thing that struck me about Creation was the power of Jennifer Connelly's portrayal of Emma Darwin. I remember seeing Connelly in Labyrinth as a child, and remarking even then on her striking looks. No longer 16 years old, Connelly's form and comportment have both matured with grace. The Emma Darwin of Creation exhibited a regal quiet elegance. In contrast, despite being a bit of a hypochondriac I grew tired of Charles Darwin's sickliness and general ennui.

Finally, a picayune but interesting observation. The young actress who played Darwin's eldest daughter, Annie, had very dark eyes. Both Paul Bettany and Jennifer Connelly have light eyes. There is then a high probability in the real world that the genetics would be such that the probability of a dark eyed child emerging from light eyed parents is low enough that one might point to misattributed paternity as the cause behind the anomaly. I note this because one of the central issues which hovers over Creation is Charles Darwin's fear of the possibility that the illnesses which his children suffered, in particular Annie, were the outcome of the fact that he and Emma were first cousins. This concern occupies a central position within the narrative arc, so I couldn't help but always note the physical evidence which strongly implied that there was in fact no consanguinity at all in that specific instance.

More like this

There's a new movie being developed on the life of Charles Darwin that actually has the potential to be good. It's based on Randal Keyne's book, Annie's Box(amzn/b&n/abe/pwll), which is an excellent source that humanizes the man well. It also has a good cast so far, although, seriously,…
You may have heard that there is a new movie about Darwin in the works, Creation, starring Paul Bettany and Jennifer Connelly. We have a synopsis now, and it isn't good news. The Darwin we meet in CREATION is a young, vibrant father, husband and friend whose mental and physical health gradually…
This week on PRI/BBC World Science: This month, the movie Creation opened in theaters across the United States. The film chronicles the life and work of Charles Darwin. The movie is directed by Jon Amiel. Paul Bettany stars as Darwin. Jennfer Connelly plays Darwin's wife, Emma. Creation is based…
This weekend marks the U.S. premiere of Creation, featuring Paul Bettany as Charles Darwin and Jennifer Connelly as his wife Emma. It's an adaptation of Darwin descendant Randal Keynes' Annie's Box, an account of Darwin's struggle to decide whether to publish the Origin while overcoming the death…

"...which strongly implied that there was in fact no consanguinity at all in that specific instance."

Now that brought me an early morning Friday smile! Thank you. But I wish you'd gone into the movie in a bit more detail than just these three paragraphs and with the same perspicacity as the one that brought out that smile.

Jennifer Connelly is hot.

By Afterthought (not verified) on 07 Feb 2010 #permalink

And she has eyebrows.

By Sandgroper (not verified) on 08 Feb 2010 #permalink