Keep an eye on the prey: You'll find the predator

In Robert Gardner's documentary film Dead Birds, the men of a highland New Guinea village guard the perimeter of the territory, watchful for men of the neighboring group who may be intent on sneaking into the gardens to capture and kill an unwitting child or woman in order to avenge a prior death. But they don't see the men sneaking through the dense riparian forest. They don't even look for them. Rather, they see the birds fly from their preferred habitat where they are foraging or resting, startled into the open by ... something. The birds belie the predator.

Today, in construction related traffic out west of the twin cities, I saw a Columba livia, aka pigeon, flying frantically across my path. Pigeons often look frantic, but this one was actually doing evasive maneuvers. Another pigeon nearby was doing the same thing, and it was not flying in parallel with the first. And a third a ways away had yet a third vector of flight. Flocking birds fly in parallel. Frantic birds do not.

ResearchBlogging.orgSo my eyes traveled to the point from which the birds may have diverged, and there was a fast flying, powerfully flapping raptor. My first thought was Falco peregrinus, the peregrine falcon, because they are big, fast, and eat birds. But after a brief moment I recognized the fluttering moth-like flight of Accipiter gentilis, the northern goshawk. Having no chance of catching up to the pigeons, the goshawk turned towards a lone tree that I always check on passing for raptors, as this is the territory of a pair of Buteo jamaicensis we have been watching for years. Just as the goshawk flew into the canopy, the canopy emptied out like a country western bar at 3:00 AM when the sheriff deputies arrive to break up a fight. Only instead of drunk cowboys it was blackbirds and sparrows which had been hoping no one would notice them, piling out of that place.

(On the way back, a half hour later, Accipiter gentilis was perched on a branch in that very tree, munching on ... something with feathers.)

In the Semliki Valley, when I was looking into the behavior of large carnivores and their eating habits and landscape movements, the same principle applied. Drive up to a herd of antelope (in this case, Kobus kob thomasi, the Ugandan kob) and they all stare at you, except three or four who are the farthest away. They are all staring at something else. Kill the engine and sit tight for 20 minutes. Over time, the kob will increasingly ignore you, and more frequently glance in a certain direction, most of them looking the same way. Now you know where gimpy old Uncle Elmo's remains lie scattered in the tall grass, two or three well fed lions napping in the nearby shade.

For years we have known that monkeys pay more attention to each other's reaction than to potential threats, under certain circumstances. Indeed, the efficacy of responding to another individual who is not a predator rather than only to predators is so marked that alarm calls have evolved in many species. Alarm calls presumably put the alarm caller at risk. A predator that elicits the call response may well have not noticed the caller, but now, there is no doubt that something to eat is nearby. Of course a well placed alarm call can also signal that the potential prey is on to the predator's approach, and will thus put the predator off. But the conventional wisdom is that alarm calling has a cost, so it must therefore have a benefit. That benefit has to be realized via kin selection, whereby relatives benefit even if some die warning others. And, once alarm calling gets going, it can play a role interspecifically, with one species gathering information by observing the behavior, including the alarm calls, of another.

A recent study by Kitchen, Bergman, Cheney, Nicholson and Seyfarth (most of you will recognized Cheney and Seyfarth as big kahunas in the primatology world) demonstrates a good example of this. One question they explored is this: Is the reaction towards the alarm calls of a different species something that is mainly encoded in the genes or something that involves more social learning?

To examine whether familiarity and/or shared vulnerability with the calling species might influence the ability of sympatric species to distinguish heterospecific alarm calls, we tested whether four ungulate species (impala: Aepyceros melampus; tsessebe: Damaliscus lunatus; zebra: Equus burchelli; wildebeest: Connochaetes taurinus) could distinguish baboon (Papio hamadryas ursinus) alarm calls from other loud baboon calls produced during intra-specific aggressive interactions ('contest' calls). Overall, subjects' responses were stronger following playback of alarm calls than contest calls. Of the species tested, impala showed the strongest responses and the greatest difference in composite response scores, suggesting they were best able to differentiate call types. Compared with the other ungulate species, impala are the most frequent associates of baboons. Moreover, like baboons, they are susceptible to both lion and leopard attacks, whereas leopards rarely take the larger ungulates. Although it seems possible that high rates of association and/or shared vulnerability may influence impala's greater ability to distinguish among baboon call types, our results point to a stronger influence of familiarity.

So, even a basic and widespread mammalian trait is shaped by experience. This should help, a little, to calibrate one's thinking on such matters when it comes to assertions that different groups of humans have genetically determined differences in ability.

The research in this paper (Comparing responses of four ungulate species to playbacks of baboon alarm calls) does have a confounding problem, which the authors recognize: Impala's 'get' interspecific calls better than, say Zebras. But they may also be more vulnerable to predators (for a number of reasons). Selection on this ability may simply be stronger for them.

So, remember this: Next time you are walking to the store and you see and hear a murder of crows which seem focused on a certain large and well flushed tree, don't think "Noisy Corvus brachyrhynchos." Rather, think "Ah ... Bubo virginianus..."

Kitchen DM, Bergman TJ, Cheney DL, Nicholson JR, & Seyfarth RM (2010). Comparing responses of four ungulate species to playbacks of baboon alarm calls. Animal cognition PMID: 20607576

More like this

I'm back! For anyone wondering why I've been reposting old pieces for the last few weeks, it's because my wife and I were enjoying a much-deserved holiday in South Africa. I'll stick a link to some photos shortly, but for the moment, here's some post-holiday geekery for you. The trip was a…
Predator-prey interactions are often viewed as evolutionary arms races; while predators improve their hunting behaviors and their ability to sneak up on their prey, the prey improve upon their abilities to detect and escape from their predators. The problem, of course, is that there is a trade-off…
[It's a really busy week over here at blog headquarters, because it is data collection week. Data collection week is awesome, but it means less time for blogging. So here's a piece from the archives. I picked this one especially for Drugmonkey, because he liked it so much.] The Harpy Eagle (Harpia…
Birds have a variety of alarm calls that warn other members of the flock about impending danger. But for some birds, the very act of taking off is enough to sound the alarm.  Mae Hingee and Robert Magrath from the Australian National University have found that crested pigeons have modified wing…

I have followed the mobbing crows to the lair (or at least, roost) of the owl on many an occasion.

I often watch our local pigeons to see what the kites are up to, too. Some of the kites seem to enjoy putting up flocks even if they don't stand a chance of making a kill - is there evidence of play in raptors, or are some of ours just eternally optimistic?

By stripey_cat (not verified) on 10 Aug 2010 #permalink

Just last week I witnessed squirrels evacuating their nest well after dark. A kit was dropped from the nest, retrieved from the ground (ignoring me, two steps away), and carried off to nearby bushes. Then I heard the owl.

Jim Corbett relied upon the calls of jungle animals in India for information re the location and movement of the tigers (many of them man eaters) that he was tracking. One species, the langhur monkey if I remember correctly (it has been a while since I re-read his books), called or gave a particular cry only when it could actually see a tiger, which was very useful on many occasions. Corbett, of course, had wandered the jungles on his own from childhood, and his knowledge of jungle lore was unsurpassed.

By Alick Newman (not verified) on 10 Aug 2010 #permalink

I have used the African sister species of the leaf-eating languar, the colobus, as a guide to the location of larger carnivores. Quite surprisingly, one time the large carnivore turned out to be a large hyena. Well outside its range!

There's a Great Horned Owl who seems to be nesting in my neighborhood this summer. I once knew it was close, because all the songbirds were just going berserk. I couldn't find the owl, until it flew out of the cottonwood tree in my yard. I'm excited to have this magnificent bird around, it means there are going to be fewer bunnies chewing on my garden.

By Benton Jackson (not verified) on 10 Aug 2010 #permalink

It may eat a bunny or two. But the often ignored fact about owls is that they eat a lot of birdies. The degree to which they do this is, in my opinion, often underestimated.

But great horned owls do like the bunnies.

Good post. Crows are much better than me at spotting kestrels, and their rattling calls 'krrrr!' alert me to overflying kestrels. I'd think they are more competitors than predators, though.

Watching the waterfowl flush at a local wildlife refuge was always a sure way to find a Bald Eagle and seeing the birds in my backyard scramble from the trees sends me running to the back porch with my bins, where I sometimes find a raptor on the prowl.

During nesting season I often find nests when witnessing smaller birds running off anything in the vicinity.

The alarm calls and the reactions of other species makes for very interesting study. Thanks for posting this great information on the predator and prey.

I have been using crows to find ospreys and bald eagles in the trees above our house. Now that I've heard their distress call many times, I recognize it and always look up to find the large predator sitting on a branch.