Seeing is Giving: Increased Church Offerings

Since it's Sunday and a week since I last blogged (forgive me Father, for I have sinned...), I thought I would keep on the church theme. No nunchuks this week (not even this kind), but I did want to share a study on how money is collected in churches can affect giving.

Economist Adriaan Soetevent collected data from 30 different Baptist churches in the Netherlands. The churches usually use closed collection bags (left) but, for 29 weeks, half of the churches were randomly chosen to replace the closed bags with open baskets (right). With the baskets, neighbors can observe each other 's contributions and churchgoers can also see the total amount of money already donated.
These churches generally have two offerings. The first offering is to collect money for internal needs of the church and the second offering is for an external cause. The study found that contributions to the second offering with an external cause initially increase by 10% when baskets are used, but this effect peters out over time. No effect was found for offerings with an internal cause. What's cool is that Soetevent even factored in variables like music and sun so that he could control for 'good mood' effect.

Also interesting was that three churches provided detailed information on the coins that were collected in each offering. When baskets were used, the portion of small coins (up to 20 eurocent) declines as churchgoers shift to giving larger coins (1 and 2 euro). People don't like to be seen giving small coins. We are all probably familiar with this feeling evoked by the coffee shop tip jar.

Soetevent, A.R. 2005. Anonymity in giving in a natural context -- a field experiment in 30 churches. Journal of Public Economics 89:2301-2323.

More like this

As promised, Greta and I have given our first matching gift to the Donors Choose challenge. We donated $103 as our 10 percent match for the $1,039 that had already been donated. We decided to donate to the two most popular proposals: Psych for Seniors and Calculate the Joy of Helping At Risk…
MRSA is coming! Run for your lives! ....this little piggy had MRSA up its nose. A recent study from the Netherlands found that 39% of slaughtered pigs carried MRSA. This is particularly surprising since MRSA rates in hospitals in the Netherlands are remarkably low. Even in the U.S., the…
The English language is full of metaphors linking moral purity to both physical cleanliness and brightness. We speak of "clean consciences", "pure thoughts" and "dirty thieves". We're suspicious of "shady behaviour" and we use light and darkness to symbolise good and evil. But there is more to…
With hundreds of seemingly worthy charities out there, how do we decide which ones to donate to? Even if we eliminate charities that aren't effective, there are still too many choices, and too little money, to donate to all of them. In the Donors Choose campaign, bloggers are going to impressive…

I had a similar experience when I was a street performer. Though I did have one further concern to deal with, if the basket, (in my case a hat) was too shallow, people would actually reach in an take stuff out. As far as the denominations went, I had one tool that most churches don't have, which was to publicly embarrass the people who tried to put pennies in the hat.

In my case, I have witnessed like this many times already. It is not necessary that we should give big amount as long as it came from the heart. I really appreciate those who give less but heartily offered than those who give big amounts but not from the heart.