Comments Problems and Policies

It's high time that I make a note about how comments are handled on this blog. This has been made particularly urgent by the fact that I was until recently getting an overwhelming amount of spam comments, which in turn led me to up the spam filter, which in turn led some real comments to be miscategorized as spam...and so forth. Big headache. Hopefully all of the real comments have now been published, and hopefully my spam filter will not swallow up any more of them.

However, there will be times in the future--and in fact there have been times in the past--when certain non-spam comments do not see publication. It's a matter of judgement on my part, essentially, but generally speaking the comments need to be substantive, and at least to some extent, they also need to be on point. So nasty personal attacks on myself or others won't be published. And albeit to a lesser extent, I will also limit completely off-point comments--especially when I am hoping for helpful feedback on a particular post but off-point comments seem likely to turn the discussion in an unwanted direction. However, there are really only a very few cases in which I'm a hardass about this. In general, when someone goes to the effort to come up with a comment and post it, I respect that intellectual activity and I unhesitatingly publish it.

That said, I do monitor all comments to ensure that they are substantive and on point. And because sometimes I'm away from my computer for a while, this means that your comment may not appear immediately. I do apologize for this, but it's the nature of the beast, and I don't see any way around it if I'm to maintain any control over the discussion and weed out attacks and the like. If you want your comments to appear immediately, then you do have an option: Sign up with a service like TypeKey, which allows me to recognize you as a "Trusted Commenter" who can post immediately. So far more than 30 individuals have been so recognized by this site.

Anyway, I have waited far too long to explain all of this--as my readers, it's your right to know. All of that said, I do think commenting has generally been working wonderfully on this blog, and I thank you for your input thus far. With about 125 entries here, there have been over 1,200 comments, which to me clearly signifies a robust and lasting intellectual dialogue. Thank you all for contributing to that.


More like this

The new digs here are taking some getting used to. The biggest change is the comment system. I don't require TypeKey authentication, but if you use a TypeKey, you relieve me of having to manually approve comments. I know the system says your comment is being held for approval otherwise, but that…
A few people have sent me e-mail to tell me that certain comments, rather than being posted immediately as they should be, are getting placed in a queue waiting for my approval. I now make it part of my daily routine to clear out such comments, so there is no need to write to tell me about them.…
(Now that I look at the title, that sounds like an incredibly tepid harness-team command. "On, Moderation! Forward, with prudent speed!" I could clear that up by adding "Comment" in the middle, but I kind of like the image...) Over at Boing Boing, Teresa Nielsen Hayden has posted a long explanation…
Two recurring issues regarding commenting: 1) There is some sort of a bug in the commenting software that occasionally causes comments to be rejected as lacking a valid email address, even when you have provided one. We think this is somehow related to the TypeKey registration required on some…

Good idea, Chris.

I'm new to typekey, so I'm not sure if this will work. I'm testing it with this message, which you may delete. I presume if I did things right, the message will show up immediately.

Didn't work. I may not be the only one who needs help with this. I discovered my "token" that I am supposed to paste into my weblog configuration screen, whatever that is. Am I missing something simple.

Enlighten all of us, please.

didn't seem to work...I couldn't figure out typekey either, or else i myself would be using it to post on my site. as it is, i have to clear my own comments!!!!

Actually, it probably isn't working. Chris happened to be approving comments as I submitted mine, which is why I thought it was working.

This is a new test. Chris, please tell us all if you needed to approve this. If so, perhaps a Typekey guru can explain to everybody how to get it to work.

I needed to approve it. You have to be Einstein to figure out Type Key.