In God Who Trusts?

There's much gnashing of teeth among the secular set these days, as South Carolina prepares to offer automobile license plates that declare "I Believe." Just in case other drivers don't get it, the specialty plates will also feature a cross, just as Florida's proposed and rejected plates would have. Is this a breach of the First Amendment, as a lawsuit filed by Americans United for Separation of Church and State claims? Or is it much ado about nothing? I can't get worked up ;;;; beyond blogging about it, of course.

South Carolina, like many other states, already offers a standard "In God We Trust" plate. One could argue that this sort of thing violates the establishment clause of the First Amendment, but one would be wasting one's time. The same thing's on American money, after all. Whether it actually does constitute a violation is no longer the point, and the phrase isn't going away.

Which is a shame, because, the way I see, it "In God We Trust" is more offensive than "I Believe." Think about it. The former assumes a collective shared trust in a supernatural entity. The latter only proclaims that the driver (or whoever registered the vehicle), holds a particular belief.

So go ahead, South Carolina. And Alabama. And whichever other states want to give their Christian drivers the satisfaction of knowing that every drop of gasoline they burn is helping spread the good news. I'd much rather be reminded that there are those who believe than be told that I do, too.

More like this

American currency uses the phrase "In God We Trust" which is a clear violation of the First Amendment of the US Constitution. This is to the First Amendment roughly like saying "No Guns Allowed" everywhere would be to the Second Amendment, but if we did that to the Second Amendment people would be…
I believe this is a violation of the First Amendment!!!! South Carolina is always trying to enhance its reputation as a conservative crazy backwater that does things like elect Joe Wilsons to the congress and flies the Rebel Flag over its state house and stuff. Recently, the state legislature…
Georgia is fishing for a new license plate design, and of course the god-botherers want to proclaim their piety on their cars. Vote fast, it expires today, apparently. Should the words "In God We Trust" be included in the new Georgia license plate design? Yes 77% No 21% Undecided 2%
A sensible federal judge has struck down South Carolina's plan to proselytize with license plates, pointing out that it violates the separation of church and state for the state to not only endorse religion, but a specific religious sect. Good work, except that it would have been such a useful…

That's fine, but only if they also offer "I Believe" plates with Stars of David, sickle moons, Pentagrams etc.

The trouble with those "special" plates is that they usually cost quite a bit more, and the surcharge (aside from a couple of bucks for processing) is donated to the relevant cause. If a state wants to issue a plate that includes a religious or political statement, they'd damn well better issue it on the same basis as regular plates, with none of the proceeds channeled into partisan pockets.

But seriously, folks, what's the point? You can get license-plate frames with just about anything you want on them - not to mention bumper stickers, magnetic fish/dolphins/FSMs, etc.

As far as I can see, the supporters of the "I Believe" plates are just trying to get away with a sneaky way of saying, "Hey, look! My state agrees with me!" For that reason, I think it's a completely f*cked-up idea. You can quote me on that, and I'm a Baptist Preacher's Kid.

By themadlolscientist (not verified) on 23 Jun 2008 #permalink

I'm from SC, but I can't complain about this too much because the largest Secular Humanist org in the state got us our own license plate years ago.

So, is this the same issue as it was in FL where the state was sponsoring the plates and the proceeds were going to a religious cause? Because IIRC, that was the "big issue" over there, in addition to the plates only being available with a cross on them (ie not a Star of David or a FSM, etc)

I don't see this as different from wildlife plates. If the state wants a few extra bucks by charging extra for it, fine. It's not like the standard plate has a cross on it. In fact, i like the plain, no real message plate.

If these things are really stamped out in prisons, then New Hampshire's standard "live free or die" has got to be the worst.

"I believe" on a license plate would be fine if the cross were replaced with a thermometer, to show that the driver believes in Global Warming!