Did the "Marsupial Lion" Climb Trees?

i-edbdaba2f434b1d5f71d026cadd909c6-thylacoleo-skull-front.JPG


Restoration of the skull of Thylacoleo. From The Ancient Life History of the Earth.


ResearchBlogging.org

Thylacoleo was one strange mammal. A close relative of living koalas, kangaroos, and wombats, the largest species of Thylacoleo were lion-sized carnivores that stalked the Australian continent between 2 million and 45 thousand years ago. Despite its popular nickname "marsupial lion", however, Thylacoleo was quite different from any feline predator. Even though its long forelimbs were tipped with retractable claws its skull more closely resembled that of a koala, with curved incisors set in front of a pair of cleaver-like shearing teeth. This resemblance caused some naturalists to believe that Thylacoleo was just another herbivore, but more recent studies have confirmed that it most certainly was a carnivore.

But what kind of predator was Thylacoleo? Some have proposed that it hunted down prey and then dragged it into the trees, as a leopard does, while others have argued that it was more lion-like in habit. The entire argument hinges upon whether Thylacoleo could climb trees or not, which in turn rests on our understanding of the predator's anatomy. The details of the skeleton of Thylacoleo, particularly its hands and feet, can provide paleontologists with clues as to what it was capable of. Unfortunately scientists have had to cope with an incomplete understanding of the hind feet of Thylacoleo for years, but a recent discovery from an Australian cave has brought new information to the discussion. As reported by paleontologists Roderick Wells, Peter Murray, and Steven Bourne in the latest issue of the Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology a complete hind foot of Thylacoleo has finally been found.

In June 2005 the owners of Henschke's Quarry in Naracoorte, Australia contacted scientist Steven Bourne about some fossils they had found in a cave on their property. When scientists began to excavate it they found, among other things, the incomplete-yet-articulated remains of several Thylacoleo carnifex, including parts of a tail and a complete hind foot. These fossils form the basis of the new study.

i-9565c095a710df23ced770c429daebfe-left-foot-thylacoleo-thumb-389x446-38614.jpg


The restored left foot of Thylacoleo carnifex. (From Wells et al, 2009)


When put together the complete left hind foot of Thylacoleo is quite different from that of a cat. Cats are digitigrade, or they are standing up on their "tippy toes" all the time. The foot of Thylacoleo, though, is plantigrade, or like ours in that the metatarsal bones support part of the foot that touches the ground (to pick an example among carnivores, bears also have plantigrade feet). The feet also have a bit of a curve to them; in the restored foot the bones around the ankle articulation slant to the left while the metatarsal and toes slant to the right.

The core of the paper is the descriptive work the scientists carried out (which includes sentences such as "The second tarsal row includes the cuboid, navicular, and the endo-, meso-, ento-cuneiforms," which brings back memories of human anatomy class), but it is what the feet can tell us about the life of Thylacoleo that is most interesting. While the parts of the foot around the ankle were most similar to the same bones in wombats and phalangers (herbivorous relatives of Thylacoleo in the group Diprotodontia) the toes were well-suited to grasping and digging into pliable surfaces. The curvature of the foot and the retractable claws that tipped the toes of Thylacoleo would have helped it to grasp tree trunks or grab onto the torso of its prey, but what did it really do?

i-4451b9f40bc6455334a53f316fb54cb0-left-foot-grasp-thumb-350x231-38616.jpg


The restored left foot of Thylacoleo carnifex, shown as if it were grasping a tree trunk or the trunk of a prey animal. (From Wells et al, 2009)


The traits that made Thylacoleo a formidable killer may have also helped it in climbing (and vice versa). As the authors state, it appears that Thylacoleo had feet that certainly could have supported it and helped to push it up into trees, and these anatomical peculiarities would have also been useful in handling prey. Thylacoleo certainly could have climbed up into trees if it wanted to, and the authors promise that they have uncovered other new anatomical evidence that suggest that the marsupial predator did climb trees. I certainly look forward to reading more about this as-yet-unpublished evidence.

Wells, R., Murray, P., & Bourne, S. (2009). Pedal Morphology of the Marsupial Lion

(Diprotodontia: Thylacoleonidae) from the Pleistocene of Australia
Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology, 29 (4), 1335-1340 DOI: 10.1671/039.029.0424

Categories

More like this

A paleontological treasure trove of fossils was discovered recently in a cave in the Nullarbor Plain in southern Australia. This discovery includes mammals, birds, reptiles and a marsupial lion, Thylacoleo carnifex (pictured), and 23 species of kangaroo, including eight of which are new to science…
The famous footage of "Benjamin," a Thylacine that died in captivity due to neglect on September 7, 1936. It was the last known living member of its species.Convergent evolution can be a tricky thing, and one of the most celebrated examples of it (at least among creationists) is the case of the…
The Australian mainland's largest extant native mammalian predator is the Spotted-tailed quoll or Tiger quoll Dasyurus maculatus. It weighs, at most, 7 kg. While rumours of Thylacine Thylacinus cynocephalus (15-30 kg) survival persist both in Tasmania and on the Australian mainland (and,…
EDGE Amphibians: World's Weirdest Creatures Just Got Weirder: A gigantic, ancient relative of the newt, a drawing-pin sized frog, a limbless, tentacled amphibian and a blind see-through salamander have all made it onto a list of the world's weirdest and most endangered creatures. Scientists Look At…

FYI, I posted this to After the Bar Closes - we are "debating" a creationist who claims that marsupial wolves (thylacines) and placental wolves are more similar than different. Not sure if you are aware of it or not, but you might get a kick (or a facepalm) out of it.

http://www.antievolution.org/cgi-bin/ikonboard/ikonboard.cgi?act=ST;f=1…

Interesting post. I'm not too familiar with ancient marsupials, but find it fascinating.

You do realize that you have just given evidence for prehistoric drop-bears?

Someone call Karen Stollznow!

I thought Thylacoleo's hind foot was supposed to have a large semi-opposable thumb.

Those illustrations look amazing. Does anyone know who did them? Many years ago, I went on a dig to the Lake Eyre region with Rod Wells, and I seem to recall him saying that he did his own art. If this is his work, I'm very impressed.

By Roger Close (not verified) on 14 Jan 2010 #permalink