Iraq: It's Not Just the Army, But the Guard Too

You might have read about (or are personally experiencing) the massive snowstorms hitting the Plains states. So what does that have to do with Iraq? From the NY Times:

Colorado and Kansas were trying to find enough helicopters capable of hauling hay bales weighing up to 1,300 pounds, said Don Ament, Colorado's agriculture director. Many helicopters in the state's National Guard fleet are in the Middle East.

That is supposed to be the primary role of the Guard: natural disaster, backup for enforcing civil order, and threats against the country itself (I refuse to use that Orwellian-sounding concoction, "the homeland"). It shouldn't be a way to permanently increase the size of the active military without reinstating the draft: the guardsmen sign on for that, but they actually have other, very important things they should be doing. Consider this the domestic equivalent of the deterioration of our foreign policy apparatus.

Tags

More like this

In the Fishlake Mountains of Utah, several fires are steadily burning. As the American West enters yet another dry season, there will almost certainly be more. Folks around these parts have been whispering about the increasing fire danger, dreading another year like 2002. We reffered to that period…
Via Radley Balko, take a look at this review of a new PBS documentary in the New York Times and this article in the Washington Post. Remember those reports from military planners saying that Rumsfeld threatened to fire anyone who talked about the need to plan for a post-war occupation of Iraq? Well…
There's been a lot of media spin and unthinking objections to the visit of President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad to the US. He was called the "modern Hitler", for example. This strikes me as both unthinking and dangerous. Ahmadinejad is his own kind of threat and problem, and comparisons to past dangerous…
I sure hope that Robert Novak is wrong about this: Whether Bush or Kerry is elected, the president or president-elect will have to sit down immediately with the Joint Chiefs of Staff. The military will tell the election winner there are insufficient U.S. forces in Iraq to wage effective war. That…

I always thought "homeland" sounded just a little bit too much like "fatherland."

Jawohl mein herren! Of course, Our Leader HAS been having a few more struggles lately. ORAC, NEIN! Do not resurrect your Fuhrer Zombie! He is NOT needed here. I only said Herr Leader Bush has could write a book called Mein Kampf, that is all...

I was a little surprised that this didn't come up more often during the Katrina fiasco. How different might that have turned out if our Guardsmen were actually back at home and able to help their fellow citizens in that time of great need rather than stuck across the globe dying in some worthless scrap desert?

Re Joshua

The reason why Guardsmen (and women) are dying in some worthless desert is because that worthless desert has the second largest oil reserves in the world.

Oil, like Communism, is a red herring. See, that would be a rational goal. Morally bankrupt, but rational. What makes you think this administration's goals are rational?

SLC -

I have to agree with joshua in a way here. A comprehensive plan to secure Iraqi oil would certainly NOT have involved the slide into chaos that Iraq has undergone. Although the assorted oil companies of the world would love unfettered access to Iraqi resources, they simply cannot operate in an environment of anarchy. Just being the most powerful force in the vicinity isn't enough.

No, the Neocons just wanted a war almost for it's own sake. There were vague ideas about obtaining oil and/or spreading democracy, but really they just wanted to show how they could kick ass. That was decided long before any of the justifications were thought of.

You might was well sat that a creationist thinks that the world was created because of percieved flaws in carbon dating, or because they were convinved by 'flood geology', when you know that they are creationists a priori, and any attempt at justifing it is just window dressing.

By Andrew Dodds (not verified) on 04 Jan 2007 #permalink