Merry Hasmonean Liberation Day!

It's the first night of Chanukah. What are you getting? One bit of disconcerting news.

A while back I heard that Mel Gibson was going to make a movie about the Macabees. If this is true, I can't wait...

(and I wonder if, like in Passion of the Christ, all of the 'good Jews' won't look very 'Jewish'...)

More like this

With Mel Gibson's DWI arrest and associated comments about Jews, re-newed attention has been focused on the content and possible effects of Gibson's The Passion of the Christ. The film depicts the high priest Caiaphas as leading an angry, bloodthirsty Jewish mob demanding the death of Jesus, and…
I refuse to see Mel Gibson's snuff film Passion because I'm pretty sure that Gibson has flipped his lid and I have no desire to see a guy in a rubber suit get flogged for 2 hours. The desire to even make such a movie suggests to me a diseased mind, and it seems like I might be getting confirmation…
...which were formerly known as newspapers. A recent column by Frank Rich makes me think that news organizations can be viable using a paid subscription model--in fact, I think they can be very successful. The problem is that they might not be very widely read. Rich, discussing the looming…
Huffington Post has a short article up about the phenomenon of Jews who don't believe in God. Turns out there are a lot of us: Atheism is entrenched in American Judaism. In researching their book American Grace, authors Robert Putnam and David Campbell found that half of all American Jews doubt…

If one stays true to history, or even to the uncensored bible, there's no good guys in the stories of the macabees. What is said first is contradicted in the second.

From my readings and sources, the macabees after capturing back their land, institutes a theocracy, every bit as repressive, if not more so than the greeks.

The entire story is problematic. Unfortunately much of the full story is left out in popular retelling.

By Jianying Ji (not verified) on 04 Dec 2007 #permalink