Merry Hasmonean Liberation Day!

It's the first night of Chanukah. What are you getting? One bit of disconcerting news.

A while back I heard that Mel Gibson was going to make a movie about the Macabees. If this is true, I can't wait...

(and I wonder if, like in Passion of the Christ, all of the 'good Jews' won't look very 'Jewish'...)

More like this

Now that Mel Gibson has apologized for his anti-Semitic tirade during his arrest for DUI last week and the ADL has accepted Gibson's apology, everyone is discussing what the fallout will be among the Hollywood elite, many of whom happen to be Jewish. Ever the contrarian, using my knowledge of the…
I've written before about Hutton Gibson (Mel Gibson's father) and serious crank, conspiracy theorist and proud Holocaust denier. I even speculated, based on Mel's cagey answers to direct questions about the Holocaust, speculating about whether he shares some of Hutton's beliefs. I ended up guessing…
I had seriously considered jumping all over this story when I first saw it early Monday morning. After all, look at the headline: Jewish groups call for hate-crime probe on Mel Gibson A more truly ominous thing to be calling for based on a drunken anti-Semitic tirade I have a hard time imagining.…
Christopher Hitchens addresses the latest media meltdown by Mel Gibson. It's great stuff; people are making all these excuses for him, that he's not really a racist, he's not really violent, he's not really a misogynist, he's not really a loathsome wackjob…but Hitchens cuts through it all. This is…

If one stays true to history, or even to the uncensored bible, there's no good guys in the stories of the macabees. What is said first is contradicted in the second.

From my readings and sources, the macabees after capturing back their land, institutes a theocracy, every bit as repressive, if not more so than the greeks.

The entire story is problematic. Unfortunately much of the full story is left out in popular retelling.

By Jianying Ji (not verified) on 04 Dec 2007 #permalink