But You Can Bury All the Hummers

Jeffrey Leonard, an environmentally friendly businessman (no, really, he is), makes an interesting case for jumpstarting the economy and Detroit by offering massive government-based rebates for their cars, including the gas guzzlers (italics mine):

Skeptics will have two major objections. The first is economic, and the second is environmental. Those who object on economic grounds would argue that Detroit has gotten into trouble because it produces poor cars at high cost, and that handing billions to the industry to help it sell more cars would simply reward a failed business model. Those who object on environmental grounds would note that much of Detroit's unsold fleet consists of gas guzzlers that should be phased out, not introduced onto our roads....

Unfortunately, Detroit will only produce cleaner, smaller cars, if the Big Three are freed of the weight of their existing inventory and prompted by the market to favor efficiency over size. So first we need consumers to buy up all of the existing new cars, and perhaps even give buyers a discount on gas for three years. Yes, gas guzzlers would be indulged, but they're going to hit our roads at some point anyway. (You can't just bury thousands of new Hummers in the ground.)

But you can bury all the cars in the ground. I give you Carhenge:

kaler1
(click to embiggen)

Seriously, it's a good point. If everyone agreed to not buy anymore SUVs, what would we do with the current inventory?

More like this

A while ago, I stumbled across this amazing article about a car mechanic, who never even graduated high school, and who has developed a diesel engine that is cleaner (biodiesel based), more fuel efficient, and more powerful than the standard engine produced by car companies (italics mine): This is…
I read these five books over about the last year or so and they all represent something I really look for in books on complex subjects -- for the most part, they concentrate on things individual people can actually do to make a difference. In this case, a difference in the future of the planet.…
Via a mailing list, Reason magazine has an article claiming that SUV's are better for the environment than hybrid cars: Spinella spent two years on the most comprehensive study to date - dubbed "Dust to Dust" -- collecting data on the energy necessary to plan, build, sell, drive and dispose of a…
Hybrid vehicles clearly have better gas mileage than many SUVs on the market, but does the gas mileage as a figure accurately represent the total energy usage required to build, market, use and destroy the vehicle? Art Spinella, in a huge study by CNW Marketing Research, has endeavored to find the…

Recycle the guzzlers. You can probably get two fuel economical cars from each SUV or Hummer.

By Robert Jase (not verified) on 28 Nov 2008 #permalink

Gotta add my vote to recycling the gas guzzlers. Let the gub'mint buy them at cost from the manufacturer, close the lines and let 'em retool.

Then we would have briefly reached the summit of destructive consumerism, like so many science fiction stories. Making things just to destroy them.

I'm with Robert and george on this one. Recycle the damn things.

Wow, Carhenge is all sorts of awesome. :)

By CaptainObvious (not verified) on 01 Dec 2008 #permalink