Some Polling Data About Science Funding

By way of a post about the popularity of healthcare, I came across some polling results from a survey that asked people whether funding for various things should increase, decrease, or stay the same. The results:

budgetpreferences
(click to embiggen)

I suppose the good news is science funding is middle of the pack. And I suppose the bad news is science funding is middle of the pack. Of course, this has to be taken with a boulder of salt, since it's not clear that respondents have any idea how much is really spent--that is, respondents could be basing their answers on complete false notions of spending levels (people always think we spend 10-100 times more on foreign aid than we actually do).

So, are these data discouraging or encouraging? (And if that's not a Rorschach Blot, I don't know what is...).

Tags

More like this

The NSF's Science and Engineering Indicators report came out not too long ago, and the bulk of it is, as usual, spent on quasi-quantitative measures of scientific productivity-- numbers of degrees granted, numbers of patent applications for various countries, etc. I find all of those things pretty…
Joseph Marr Cronin and Howard E. Horton describe the extent to which college tuitions appear to have become the next economic bubble: According to the National Center for Public Policy and Higher Education, over the past 25 years, average college tuition and fees have risen by 440 percent -- more…
This morning, my good friend Orac sent me a link to an interesting piece of bad math. Orac is the guy who really motivated me to start blogging; I jokingly call him my blogfather. He's also a really smart guy, not to mention a genuinely nice one (at least for a transparent box of blinking lights…
Attention conservation notice: 3000 words about how smart people who ought to know better are reading way too much into a poll. Last May, NCSE reported on a poll on evolution conducted by Virginia Commonwealth University. The results were, to my eye, in line with most of the other polling out…

I thought it interesting that, overall, people didn't want to reduce spending on anything. Only one item, poor people in other countries, even had a plurality in favor of reducing spending (34 to 33 reducing vs keeping it the same).

That's great and all, but probably explains some of our budget issues :p

But look at it this way: since 40% say "keep it the same" then 79% are actually "on our side" with only 14% calling for a decrease. I always have a hard time understanding "unsure" selections in surveys like this.

By NewEnglandBob (not verified) on 24 Jul 2009 #permalink

A number of years back, I saw a poll where people were asked how they would divide up the budget pie for Defense, Education, Research, Social Welfare, etc. I think the categories were fewer in number and slightly more broad than the above. I remember that both education and research both wound up with a MUCH bigger part of the pie than they really get. The only area that got a lot less was defense/military spending. Apparently even many hawks didn't realize how much of the budget goes there.