How to Deficit Spend Stupidly

I've often discussed on this blog how the advantage of having a fiat currency is that one can deficit spend when you need to (think of it as being on the gold standard, except that you can mine as much gold as you need, when you need it)*. Of course, if you deficit spend when there is no idle capacity (human or mechanical) in the real economy, this can lead to inflation. Likewise, if you flood a sector or group of people with dollars when they don't need it, this also will lead to inflation and price distortion, and can result in socially undesirable outcomes (e.g., rampant income inequality).

The point is that deficit spending itself isn't bad, it's how one creates deficits that can be the problem. Republican governor of Florida Rick Scott has decided to be the poster child for bad deficit spending (italics mine):

Yes, Scott is proposing $5 billion in state spending reductions (in absolute terms, not reductions from some sort of current-services budget). Many of these cuts seemed to be ideologically driven, such as the decimation of the state Department of Community Affairs, which runs growth-management programs hated by developers; and a (roughly) ten percent cut in K-12 education, part and parcel of the state GOP's war with teachers and other state employees.

But the size of the cuts wouldn't be nearly so high if Scott were not also insisting on major tax cuts, notably in corporate taxes (due to be phased out entirely in a few years) and in state-controlled property taxes that support public schools.

Moreoever, nestled in his budget proposal are spending increases that are designed to redistribute resources according to conservative ideological prescriptions. Most remarkable is his request for $800 million (over two years) for "economic development incentives," which almost certainly means a gubernatorially-controlled slush fund to be used to bribe companies to relocate to Florida through tax abatements, free government services, and other subsidies. And even as he sought major cuts in public school funding (in a state already facing something of a school financing crisis), he managed to find room to propose $250 million in private-school vouchers.

...He may or may not get his way on the details with a Republican-controlled legislature, but he has certainly initiated class warfare, and a redistribution of public resources to those "job creators" at the top of the income and power pyramid, with a vengeance.

This is the

More like this

I've written before about the tyranny of double-entry bookkeeping when it comes to budget deficits: decreasing public debt requires either an increase in total private debt or a decrease in the 'trade deficit' (current account balance). Rotten Apple has a very clear explanation of how this works…
I'm pleasantly surprised by this column at MarketWatch. Actually more like gobsmacked. I realize the post's title is a wee bit obscure, so some background is order. One of the reasons I write about budget deficit hysteria all the time is that the belief that WE MUST REDUCE TEH DEFICITZ! NAO! is…
Actually, it will probably be several decades. While details of the budget ceiling negotations haven't been released, the initial reports sound pretty awful, with $2.4 trillion of cuts over ten years with $1 trillion in discretionary cuts (that's stuff like NIH and NSF, by the way). It's pretty…
A constant refrain one hears when the deficit hawks let loose their piteous cries is that we are living beyond our means. Surely, our budget deficit and national debt are signs of that. Lord, for the sins which we have committed before thee... Or not so much. As I've discussed before, public…

This is the

... what?

By D. C. Sessions (not verified) on 14 Feb 2011 #permalink

I think you'll find the answer in Castle of Aaargh.....

Hey, are you going to finish this post. And what footnote were you going to add? Or is that an endnote and I gotta go to the of the blog for the info?

By Juicyheart (not verified) on 15 Feb 2011 #permalink

Here's some more stupidity from Gov. Scott:…

This is the man who as a candidate promised to create 700,000 jobs in Florida, and who's motto was "Let's get to work". So, his first budget proposal cuts education dramatically (causing mass teacher layoffs), and then he wants to pass on 2.4 billion in federal money for high speed rail that would create 1000 permanent jobs and 23,000 during construction.