Dear Neurontic

If I understand correctly, the seat of emotion is in the brain, in the limbic system, so why do I get butterflies in my stomach when I'm nervous?

Stomach Upset

Dear Stomach Upset,

Remember that Steve Martin movie The Man With Two Brains? Well, it turns out they got the number wrong. It should have been The Man With Three Brains. There was the brain Dr. Hfuhruhurr carried around in the jar (voiced by the girl from Wings if I remember correctly), the one in his skull, and the one in his stomach . . . That's right, his stomach. According to researchers in the field of neurogastroenterology, each of us has not one, but two brains: One that lives on top of our necks, and a second in our guts.

The brain in your stomach is called the enteric nervous system, and it is "located in sheaths of tissue lining the oesophagus, stomach, small intestine and colon." What identifies this part of your anatomy as a brain, you ask? Like the brain in your melon, the enteric nervous system houses a network of neurons, which send messages back and forth via neurotransmitters, like serotonin and dopamine.

While the enteric nervous system is an independent entity, it generally works in tandem with your brain. When something upsets you mentally, the feeling often manifests in your stomach. How?

When the central brain encounters a frightening situation, it releases stress hormones that prepare the body to fight or flee . . . The stomach contains many sensory nerves that are stimulated by this chemical surge--hence "butterflies" . . . Fear also causes the vagus nerve [a nerve connecting the abdomen with the brain stem] to "turn up the volume" on serotonin circuits in the gut . . . thus overstimulated, the gut goes into higher gear and diarrhea results.

(Complex and Hidden Brain, Blakeslee, The New York Times)

Scientists believe that the gut's brain is responsible for more than butterflies and the occasional bout of diarrhea. They think that disorders like irritable bowel syndrome, and chronic abdominal pain may be the result of malfunctions in the enteric nervous system. Researchers in the growing field of neurogastroenterology are currently working to root out the causes of stomach complaints like these.

The question remains: What is the purpose of this second brain? Dr. David Wingate of the University of London believes that that the gut's brain is a vestige of our evolutionary past. Nervous systems first evolved in tubular animals that attached to rocks and waited for food to float by. As organisms grew more complex, they required a more highly calibrated system for seeking out food and mating partners. This need gave rise to the central nervous system. But the ability to eat and digest was so paramount to the organism's survival, according to Wingate, that it was too dangerous to stow it the head. Instead, evolution engineered a separate circuit - the enteric nervous system - to control these drives, which was housed in the stomach.

The moral of the story? Falling prey to stress-induced stomach cramps doesn't mean you have a weak stomach--it means you have a "smart" one.

Got a question for Neurontic? Email orlivan [at]

More like this

When I was a lowly grad student at Columbia U, I was part of a small and cozy department headed by Michael Gershon. Now Professor Gershon is an expert of the enteric nervous system, or the nerve system of the gut. He gained celebrity status due to the fact that he had written a book called The…
The boyfriend and I are headed out of town for a couple of weeks, folks. I plan to post, but it'll be intermittent. In the meantime, send in your 'Dear Neurontic' questions to orlivan [at] Best, Orli
Asian house shrew image by W.A. Djatmiko (Wie146) - Own work, CC BY-SA 3.0. The stomach and small intestine of many species moves rhythmically during fasting, something called the rhythmic 'migrating motor complex', or MMC. The MMC has 3 phases: no contraction, intermittent small contractions…
A new Neurontic feature, Sunday's Silly Science Roundup showcases scientific findings that make you go "duh." After spending a great deal of time and money, a group of researchers at University College London are willing to go out on a limb and say "Irrational Decisions are Based on Emotion."…

"evolution ENGINEERED a separate circuit"?

By Yonatan Amir (not verified) on 09 Mar 2007 #permalink


Round two to Lee Ann.

Does intuition exist in our enteric nervous systems?

Wow! I did not know that we had "two brains". This is very interesting. I am sad that we were not taught this at school.

-Vishvas Vasuki

By vishvas vasuki (not verified) on 06 Mar 2007 #permalink

My gut brain was sending me a very strong message before I got married. I should have listened!

the explanation from evolutionary pov is silly, there is nothing vestigal, the entire body is a living and responding entity, chakras, nadis, nerves, the five pranas, sublte energy body... the enteric nervous system is an aliveness associated with food and assimilation and digestion and elimination... acts that are potentially disruptive cause it to fire in unusual ways, but it is nothing but life living with its usual voraciousness.... you have to study consciousness boys, before you can even think about physiology

By ana ma roopa (not verified) on 09 Mar 2007 #permalink

Douchebag alert! beep beep beep! Douchebag alert!

I must confess that this article is my first contact with the idea of the stomach as a semi-autonomous portion of the nervous system. On the other hand, you neglected to mention Neurocardiology, which suggests the same concept applies to the heart as well.

The "flaky" chakra people say there are 7 centers major subdivisions of consciousness that roughly correspond to the endocrine glands in what they term the physical body, which is the only body that science officially recognizes.

With the stomach, heart and the traditional brain, that brings the total to 3. Personally, I'd bet that if one researched the gonads, the adrenal and the thyroid areas, one would be able to find that there are nervous clusters in those regions which exhibit this semi autonomy as well. These mystics are not all wackos or charlatans. They are people who have taken up the examination of the experience of living using the tool of introspection with a level of discipline that few are able to muster.

Pejorative name calling is a perennially signature of sophmoric understanding.

By SM Smithfield (not verified) on 09 Mar 2007 #permalink

You just perpetrated some name-calling yourself, mister/miss. You just had to spend $.25 for those long words there. I think I win for efficiency.

you are so pwned, dude.