Disappearing bees are lost in translation

Since late 2006, honeybees in Europe and North America have been mysteriously disappearing. Once abuzz with activity, hives suddenly turned into honeycombed Marie Celestes. They still had plentiful supplies of honey, pollen and youngsters but the adult workers vanished with no traces of their bodies. The phenomenon has been dubbed colony collapse disorder (CCD). In the first winter when it struck, US hive populations crashed by 23% and in the next winter, they fell again by a further 36%.

Eager to avert the economic catastrophe that a bee-less world, scientists have been trying to find the cause behind the collapse. Amid wackier explanations like mobile phone radiation and GM crops, the leading theories include sensitivity to pesticides, attacks by the vampiric Varroa mite or a parasitic fungus called Nosema, infections by various viruses, or combinations of these threats.

In 2007, US scientists thought they had revealed the main villain in the piece, by showing that the an imported virus - Israeli acute paralysis virus (IAPV)- was strongly linked to empty hives. But since then, another group showed that IAPV arrived in the US many years before the first signs of CCD were reported. Other related viruses have also been linked to CCD hives, including Kashmir bee virus (KBV) and deformed wing virus (DWV). 

To pare down these potential culprits, Reed Johnson from the University of Illinois compared the genetic activity of bees from over 120 colonies, including some affected by CCD and healthy ones that were sampled before the vanishing began. He looked at their digestive systems - one of the most places where infections and environmental toxins would start wreaking havoc.

The analysis didn't offer any simple answers, but Johnson found some evidence to suggest that CCD bees have problems with producing proteins. In animal cells, proteins are manufactured in molecular factories called ribosomes. These factories assemble proteins by translating instructions encoded within molecules of RNA. Ribosomes themselves are partially built form a special type of RNA known as rRNA. And when Johnson looked at the guts of CCD bees, he found unusually high levels of fragmented rRNA.


It's not entirely clear what causes these fragments, although some of the viruses implicated in CCD have been known to attack and interfere with ribosomes. Nor is it clear what the presence of the rRNA fragments means for the bees. One plausible explanation is that the CCD bees have more broken ribosomes, and have problems with producing proteins on demand. That in turn would limit their ability to respond to environmental threats like pesticide poisoning or viral infections.

On the surface, it looks like Johnson has discovered a tidy chain of events. Multiple viral infections could lead to CCD, via an inability to produce new proteins that renders bees susceptible to pesticides, parasites and other threats. Indeed, although Johnson found that no single infection separated the CCD colonies from the healthy ones, the sick bees were generally carrying a higher burden of viruses and parasites.

But this tale is more complicated than it seems. Other than an abundance of rRNA, Johnson found that 65 genes that were activated differently among sick bees compared to healthy ones. Many of the affected genes have no known function yet. However, none of these were known immune genes, which you would expect to be deployed in response to infections, or detox genes, which would help to nullify any poisons that the bees inadvertently consumed. While these pattern's aren't enough to rule out the influences of pesticides or diseases, they certainly don't support the ideas.

The next step for Johnson is to try and show that being infected with many viruses results in more rRNA fragments, malfunctioning ribosomes, fewer important proteins and poorer health. Until then, the CCD mystery remains open.

Reference: PNAS doi:10.1073/pnas.0906970106

Image: Bee by Bjorn Appel

More on bees: 

i-77217d2c5311c2be408065c3c076b83e-Twitter.jpg i-3a7f588680ea1320f197adb2d285d99f-RSS.jpg

More like this

This article is reposted from the old Wordpress incarnation of Not Exactly Rocket Science. There's been more work on CCD since, but I'm reposting this mainly because of some interesting follow-up research that will I will post about tomorrow. In 2006, American and European beekeepers started…
Since ~2006, honey bee colonies in the US have been dropping dead overnight. Literally. They call it 'colony collapse disorder'. While large populations of organisms dying is disturbing, no matter the species, we need honey bees-- they help pollinate so many of our crops. I grew up in the banks…
We don't know if the virus is the causal agent, but a recent Science paper used a metagenomics approach to find that bees from colonies that have collapsed are infected with a virus (and it's the same virus in different colonies). Essentially, the researchers ground up bees, sequenced the whole…
I first wrote about honey bee colony collapse disorder (CCD) in 2009-- Since ~2006, honey bee colonies in the US have been dropping dead overnight. Literally. They call it ‘colony collapse disorder’. While large populations of organisms dying is disturbing, no matter the species, we need honey bees…

It's a rather common tactic for organisms to switch off protein translation when they detect viral infection. Infection with viruses is often detected as the presence of double stranded RNA particles or messages which appear physically or biochemically different to standard cellular mRNAs (perhaps differing in their 5' or 3' elements).
Is there a comparison to a separate type of virus attack to show that the things they noticed were specific for this particular virus rather than simply generalized symptoms of viral infection?

I love you for the Marie Celeste reference. I read a book about that as a kid and always wondered why it wasn't as famous as other doomed ships.

Yeah, I can do science AND history!

I'd like to think this is what's really happening to all the bees.

"Marie Celeste" is a common error; the ship was the Mary Celeste.

By Dan Milton (not verified) on 25 Aug 2009 #permalink

Interesting! I do hope they solve it before we run out of flowering plants. The carpenter bees seem to be doing most of the pollination around here (Toronto area; not sure what's happening in the country--perhaps white-faced hornets).

Maybe it's just one too many factors. I'm worrying about the trees. Foliage seems to be restricted to a smaller length of the tip of each twig, year by year--but to the inobservant they still look normal. They've gone from opaque to see-through in the last 30 years. In a few years they won't be making any leaves at all.

Sorry, that didn't make sense. I meant maybe it's many little factors each reducing bee viability. Good on them for persevering.

I got one of those "too many comments in a short time" errors. I don't know about Scienceblog's management, but when I make a mistake I want to correct it right away so that it directly follows the comment with the error.