The G-Word

Scott Aaronson talks sense about religion, in response to an emailer who stopped reading his quantum computing lectures because he made references to "God":

What I'm trying to say, Bill, is this: you can go ahead and indulge yourself. If some of the most brilliant unbelievers in history -- Einstein, Erdös, Twain -- could refer to a being of dubious ontological status as they would to a smelly old uncle, then why not the rest of us? For me, the whole point of scientific rationalism is that you're free to ask any question, debate any argument, read anything that interests you, use whatever phrase most colorfully conveys your meaning, all without having to worry about violating some taboo. You won't endanger your immortal soul, since you don't have one.

See, this is why he's the world's second funniest physics blogger, and I'm just a cranky guy with a website. I would've just muttered "Oh, Jesus Christ, lighten up, willya?" and gone about my business. Scott turned it into something good, and there's more good stuff in the comments.

Tags
Categories

More like this

Scott Aaronson has a revelation: it's OK for a "disbelieving atheist infidel heretic" to refer to a god. What I'm trying to say, Bill, is this: you can go ahead and indulge yourself. If some of the most brilliant unbelievers in history — Einstein, Erdös, Twain — could refer to a being of dubious…
The second half of the NOVA special on "Absolute Zero" aired last night. Like the first installment, it was very well done, avoiding most of the traps of modern pop-science television. There were some mysterious shots of amusement park rides when they started talking about quantum mechanics, and I'…
I forgot to link to Sunday's New York Times article about D-Wave and their controversial claim to have made a working quantum computer, which prominently features quotes from the world's second funniest physics blogger: Scott Aaronson, a theoretical computer scientist at the Institute for Quantum…
I'm currently reading Scott Aikin's and Robert Talisse's book Reasonable Atheism: A Moral Case for Respectful Disbelief. I'm finding it a strange experience. I agree with most of their substantive points, but I always find it off-putting when writers start boasting of their own civility and…

The world's funniest physics blogger is, in Scott's estimation, the deeply unhinged Lubos Motl. The fact that he's not trying to be funny just makes it funnier. Or something.