Open Source Musical Interpretations

While poking around to double-check the lyrics for several of the songs in the previous post, I stumbled across SongMeanings.net, which turns out to be fairly entertaining.

As the name suggests, it's a site where you can find a pretty comprehensive list of song lyrics by different artists, with notes attached regarding the meaning of the lyrics. The thing is, these are basically comment threads, so most of the people posting are just throwing out wild-assed guesses, not drawing on any particular knowledge.

This leads to some interesting discussions when applied to famously inscrutable artists like Bob Dylan ("Tangled Up in Blue"), or the "soaring vagueness" of U2 ("Ultraviolet (Light My Way)"), or songs that I've always vaguely wondered about like "Oliver's Army". The real genius is in seeing people discuss ephemeral pop songs-- to choose a few suggested by the 80's shuffle, there's "Little Red Corvette" or "Jump" or, God help me, "Putting on the Ritz" by Taco (which, I hasten to add, I don't actually own, but couldn't resist looking at....).

This is either absolutely brilliant, or kind of sad, and I'm not quite sure which.

Tags

More like this

Twelve of the Top 25 Most Played songs were correctly identified over the weekend. Given the obscurity of some of these, that's pretty impressive. I think there's only one that should've been obvious that didn't get guessed. Full answers are below the fold. (Edited to add: If you enjoy this sort of…
I bought the Witmark Demos a week or so ago, because I could always use another 50 Bob Dylan songs, and listening to them on shuffle play has managed to earworm me with one song in particular, "I Shall Be Free", which it occurs to me has great current relevance: Well, my telephone rang it would not…
We had an appointment yesterday for a fetal echocardiogram, to look for heart problems that might've caused the scary first trimester screen result back in January. This was basically a high-resolution ultrasound focussed on the heart (with Doppler velocity imaging to look at blood flow), and after…
It feels a little weird not to be doing a Short Story Club entry, so here's a different sort of pop culture item: Over at EphBlog, my classmate Derek Catsam has decided to break up the carnival of reactionary politics by commenting on great albums, jumping off from Spin's Top 125 of the Last 25…

Oh, dear.

I do actually own a copy of Taco's "Puttin' On The Ritz."

Regarding the commentary, it was rather sad that nobody seemed to know that the music and lyrics were by Irving Berlin (from the 1930 movie "Puttin' On The Ritz").

The British Army, which is not "Royal", was established as a standing force by one Oliver Cromwell as an executive arm of Parliament, which funded it.
This was a major constitutional bedrock, and one which the US inherited in its framework.
FIrst change is that there was a standing army, rather than a gathering of militias and private household retainers (including royal household); second that it was funded directly by Parliament from revenue, not royal reserves; and thirdly that they answered to the elected representatives, not an executive commander. Shifted the balance of power "permanently" from the executive to the legislature.

The song itself is very straightforward, and was written at a time of high unemployment and international political tension in the 80s.