Football: That Was Quick

I don't normally pay much attention to preseason or off-season sports, and my isolation has been better than usual this year with regard to the NFL, what with being in Japan for the past three weeks. As a result, I vaguely expected my Giants to suck this year, but I was not prepared for the season to be effectively over after one game.

Hyperbole, you say? Maybe, but it's not just about the loss to the hated Cowboys, or even the injuries to key players, it's about the way they lost, and the players they have left.

Consider: what were their weaknesses last year? Well, their big problem was a pass defense with the porosity of aerogel. What did they trot out last night? The same players in the same positions, in the same schemes. The Cowboys had basically one play that they ran about ten times, for big gains every time-- that little slant route over the middle. It didn't really matter who they put on that route-- Terrell Owens, Jason Witten, Sam freakin' Hurd-- they were completely open every time.

What's their other big defensive weakness been? Well, depth on the defensive line has been a big problem. Michael Strahan hasn't played a full season since about 2002, and he wasn't even in camp for most of this year. What happened last night? Osi Umenyiora went down in the second quarter, and an out-of-shape Strahan wound up having to play the entire game, because they apparently don't have anybody else at that position.

I'm ready to write this season off as a dead loss not because of any specific plays or players, but because there's no sign of any change in the basic pattern that has led them to collapse the last few years. Or even a hint of recognition that there is a pattern here. It's the same goddamn things going wrong in the same goddamn way, and Tom Coughlin stands there with the same look of blank incredulity on his face, as if he had never seen it before.

On the bright side, Eli Manning and the offense looked pretty good. Of course, Manning banged up his shoulder, and Jared Lorenzen, their backup QB who's the size of a defensive lineman, went into a slide two yards short of the line on fourth down, down ten with two and a half minutes left.

Oh, well. At least this will free up some of the mental energy I usually use for caring about football to put toward other things...

More like this

Wherein the Mad Biologist indulges in Compulsive Contrarian Disorder. There's been a lot of talk about the National Football League's new rules about concussions, which force a player to stay out of a game during which he received a concussion. On the one hand, this absolutely is the right thing…
by Michael Lax, MD, MPH The news that almost one third of NFL football players can expect to suffer the effects of brain trauma made headlines in major media. While it is not surprising that large men, often leading with their heads, bashing each other week after week suffer some consequences,…
Folks have been enthusiastically commenting around the clock on the possiblity of using prisoners in clinical trials. Meanwhile, Thomas Hargrove has analyzed obesity and death rates in the National Football League. He suggests that those pharmaceutical companies with anti-obesity drugs might be…
As I promised the other day, I went to Carrboro Century Center this afternoon (right after meeting with Anton around the corner) to see the Island Projects designed by the Chapel Hill High School students of Rob Greenberg. I did not see all of them - they were doing this in "shifts" throughout the…

"Tom Coughlin stands there with the same look of blank incredulity on his face, as if he had never seen it before."

It's not really blank incredulity. It's more uncomprehending confusion. It's like a cat's expression when he has been looking out the window and a big bird just swoops by out of nowhere. He really needs a big tattoo on his forehead that is just big block letters: "ZOMFG!! WTF!?"

By PhysioProf (not verified) on 10 Sep 2007 #permalink