Kooks With Prestigious Prizes

The Times today has an article on famous scientists who have nutty ideas, inspired by the James Watson kerfuffle of the last couple of weeks. Of course, they had to mention at least one kooky physicist, leading to this wonderful set of paragraphs:

Sometimes the wandering from one's home turf extends all the way to the paranormal. In 2001, when officials of the Royal Mail, the British postal service, issued a package of stamps commemorating the centenary of the Nobel Prize, they sought the counsel of Brian Josephson, who shared the prize for physics in 1973 for his superconductivity research. Physicists across Britain recoiled when an official pamphlet accompanying the stamps predicted that quantum mechanics might lead to an understanding of mental telepathy.

"Perhaps we should have checked that," a spokeswoman for the Royal Mail told Nature at the time. "But if he has won a Nobel Prize for his work, that should give him some credibility."

With science treading right to the bleeding edge of the knowable, maybe the Royal Mail can be forgiven for mistaking pseudoscience for the real thing. In an article in The Observer of London, David Deutsch, a quantum theorist at Oxford University, dismissed Dr. Josephson's speculations as "utter rubbish." Dr. Deutsch is known for proposing the existence of a multiplicity of parallel universes.

Well, yeah, but that's totally reasonable. I mean, everyone knows about that...

More like this

A sad and sordid story from the Times Higher Education following the rescinding of invitations to a conference on quantum foundations: Details of the conference in August for experts in quantum mechanics sounded idyllic. Participants were due to discuss "de Broglie-Bohm theory and beyond" in the…
I have a big stack of exams and lab reports to grade, so I need to go off someplace where I don't have Internet access and do that. In my absence, here's a Dorky Poll question inspired by recent news: Which Nobel laureate (in any field) is the craziest? There's no real shortage of scientists who…
Postdoc in Italy, AQIS 2008 Call for Papers, the Register reports on QUEST, and the New Scientist morphs into the No Scientist. There is a postdoc position available in Italy: A Post Doctoral fellowship in Quantum Information Theory is available at the University of Camerino, Department of Physics…
Two notes on chairs. Michael Green is the new Lucasian chair of Mathematics replacing the esteemed Stephen Hawking. Green helped sparked the great optimism in string theory by discovering with John Schwarz the Green-Schwarz anomaly cancellation mechanism. Elsewhere, the Perimeter Institute has…

I'm sort of suprised that in the wake of the Watson comment, no-one has yet mentioned William Shockley, the physicist who shared the 1956 Nobel Prize with John Bardeen and for Walter Brattain for co-inventing the transistor, and whose views on race and eugenics actually went quite a bit further than Watson's.

Didn't Linus Pauling tell the world that the common cold could be cured by massive doses of Vitamin C?

Didn't Linus Pauling tell the world that the common cold could be cured by massive doses of Vitamin C?

And heart disease and AIDS ...

They got two that immediately came to mind, Kary Mullis and Fred Hoyle, but I would also add Lynn Margulis who has recently become an HIV denialist and a 911 Truther.

By Chris Noble (not verified) on 29 Oct 2007 #permalink