There's Methane in Them Thar Planets

The coolest-sounding science news of the moment is undoubtedly "Hubble Finds First Organic Molecule on an Exoplanet""

NASA's Hubble Space Telescope (HST) has made the first detection ever of an organic molecule in the atmosphere of a Jupiter-sized planet orbiting another star. This breakthrough is an important step in eventually identifying signs of life on a planet outside our solar system.

Of course, that sounds a little more dramatic and impressive than the reality: they used absorption spectroscopy of the plent's atmosphere to detect the presence of methane in its atmosphere. Now, technically, methane is an organic molecule, but if you stick "organic molecule" into a headline, most people are going to think of complex hydrocarbon chains and that sort of thing.

That doesn't mean it's not an impressive result-- it is. It's pretty amazing that they're able to get this information at all. I continue to be very impressed at the ingenuity of astronomers. And also at their boundless capacity for surprise:

The astronomers were surprised to find that the planet has more methane than predicted by conventional models for "hot Jupiters." "This indicates we don't really understand exoplanet atmospheres yet," said [JPL's Mark] Swain.

You know, at this point, after however many dozens of extrasolar planet detections that completely confound the current models of these systems, I think I'd only be surprised if a result did match the predictions of the conventional model...

More like this

"Continue to surprise those who would put you in a neat demographic. Be insistently curious." -Gordon Gee Twenty years ago, our Solar System was the only one we knew of that we were certain had planets orbiting around a main-sequence star. Image credit: retrieved from Universe-Review.ca. Perhaps…
"Day after day, day after day, We stuck, nor breath nor motion; As idle as a painted ship Upon a painted ocean. Water, water, every where, And all the boards did shrink; Water, water, every where, Nor any drop to drink." -Samuel Taylor Coleridge, Rime of the Ancient Mariner Despite the discovery of…
There's a new paper in Nature announcing the detection of water vapor in the atmosphere of a "hot Jupiter" orbiting a distant star. There's also a story on Physics Web and a press release from the Spitzer Telescope group, if you'd like some stuff you can read without a subscription to Nature. The…
"We are all captives of the pictures in our head -- our belief that the world we have experienced is the world that really exists." -Walter Lippmann For a long time, humans have wondered about life on other worlds, and about worlds around other stars. Until the 1990s, this was mostly speculation…

Methane? That's handy; at least when we get there, our BBQ grills will work.

But how will we power our guitars? Is there a magnetosphere?

By Johan Larson (not verified) on 20 Mar 2008 #permalink

Once upon a time, it occurred to me that "mining" for methane on Jupiter (say) would end our energy crisis for centuries to come. But if we imported too much methane, we would have to start worrying about an oxygen shortage, which would be a more severe problem than an energy shortage.

I wonder if there are any plentiful extraterrestrial supplies of oxygen? I don't think so---oxygen is a product of photosynthesis and doesn't occur in pure form without plants.

And also at their boundless capacity for surprise

Count the microwave engineers in on that trait. Every year at MTT IMS for the past several years, ever since the first practical realizations of metamaterials, there have been panel sessions, poster sessions, and collections of talks all organized around the principle, "Yeah!! Maxwell's Equations still work! Maxwell rocks, d00de!"

Which, yes, Maxwell does rock. But perhaps if we could now throttle back on the enthusiasm and restrict ourselves at the engineering conferences to papers which point the way to better engineering designs....

By John Novak (not verified) on 20 Mar 2008 #permalink

"Now, technically, methane is an organic molecule, but if you stick "organic molecule" into a headline, most people are going to think of complex hydrocarbon chains and that sort of thing."

I'm not sure I'd agree. I suppose things are quite different on planets with different conditions, but you can't expect to find things much more interesting than methane in the atmosphere. Remember, anything with more than 3 or 4 carbons won't be a gas.

But Jupiter has more methane than Jupiter-like planets. I remember when Shoemaker-Levy 9 hit, and everyone was going, "Where'd all that methane come from? That wasn't supposed to be there!"

... you can't expect to find things much more interesting than methane in the atmosphere. Remember, anything with more than 3 or 4 carbons won't be a gas.

That rather depends on the temperature and the pressure, doesn't it? E.g., octane (C8H18) has a boiling point (at 1atm) of 125 Celsius/399 K, which is significantly cooler than the temperature of a typical "hot Jupiter".

Or just look at some of the things you can get in Titan's atmosphere, starting with benzene and going on up to things with masses of several thousand Daltons (e.g., this article).