Poll: Incredibly Important Cultural Question

Prompted by this and this, among other things, one of the critical questions of the modern age:

Magic is a classical phenomenon, no matter what you may have heard, so you can choose one and only one option.

More like this

I had a bit of an epiphany this weekend about economics. More accurately, I had an epiphany about why it is that economics rubs me the wrong way as often as it does. Let me get the disclaimer out of the way up front: I'm not bugged by all economists. I'm probably not bothered by all economic…
Yesterday, I wrote about selfless capuchin monkeys, who find personal reward in the act of giving other monkeys. The results seemed to demonstrate that monkeys are sensitive to the welfare of their peers, and will make choices that benefit others without any material gain for themselves. Today,…
The San Francisco Chronicle reports that the University of California is getting serious about ethics -- by requiring all of its 230,000 to take an online ethics course. Yeah, throwing coursework at the problem will solve it.* Indeed, I'm not sure I'd even want to count this as "coursework" given…
The "peer reviewers get worse" item in this morning's Links Dump drew an immediate comment elsewhere to the effect of "of course they do, because they start pawning reviews off on their students. This one was a surprise to me, so here's a quick poll to see if my subfield of physics is really that…

@Doug

Fortunately for Ron, it's in Hermione's bag.

By NoAstronomer (not verified) on 15 Jul 2011 #permalink

That's a bad thing, NoAstronomer?

Harry's a jerk.

I think the thing that confuses the issue, is that the whole magic-using community is supposed to have an "outcast nerd" relationship with the rest of the world, so by that standard *everybody at Hogwarts* is a nerd (although some are clearly nerdier than others).

That said, Harry is clearly a jock relative to the background he is in (although he would probably be a nerd in a "muggle" school).

I agree with Tim @4. Mostly. There's the nerdy magic-users and the aristocratic magic-users.

Slytherin is pretty much purely aristocrats. Ravenclaw is pretty much purely nerds. Hufflepuff is almost entirely nerds (no aristocrats there) and Gryffendor is mostly aristocrats.

Harry has aristocratic blood, but because of his up-bringing, ends up having some of the mentality of a nerd. Once he gets a taste of fame, however, he ends up mostly jock.

Interesting that the two nerdiest characters (Hermione and Snape) end up in the aristocratic houses.