From Randy Olson: The Governator Reaches for Likeability

i-09b4d6cf56e2747704438a518685a3ed-arnold_schwarzenegger_suit.jpg

Governor Ahnold has been pushing an environmental agenda in California (in 2004, for instance, he jump-started the process to establish 29 marine protected areas along the coast) and now he's wading into the subject of environmental communication. And he's on the right track (maybe he's been reading Nisbet and Mooney's editorial on Framing Science).

In a speech yesterday at Georgetown University he scolded environmentalists for their basic style of communication, saying the environmental movement needs to get to the point where it's "no longer being seen as a nag or a scold" (hitting some notes similar to the book I'm writing titled, "Don't Be Such a Scientist" in which I comment on the downside of being overly literal).

And he said the environmental movement needs to become "sexy, attractive," which makes me think of my silly mother in Kansas, Muffy Moose, and her blog post a while back about the bimbo in the tv ads who lost weight and says, "I'm sex-eeee!" (see her December 22 post).

Here in Hollywood, sexy and attractive tends to conjure up images of plastic and phony--not clear that's necessarily the winning strategy.

The term the Governator was reaching for was, "likeable." The environmental movement needs to make itself more likeable. And on that note he's absolutely right. The only problem is that everyone wants to be likeable. And if it was that easy, everyone would achieve it. It's a bit like good taste -- everyone would like to have good taste (well, almost everyone--I've got a few white trash friends who relish their bad taste), but is it really something that can be taught? Who knows, but what can definitely be taught is how to avoid bad taste (list your own examples here), AND...how to avoid being unlikeable (by not being a nag or a scold, as Ahnold said).

More like this

Randy Olson is a film maker and marine biologist who has focused in recent years on the critique of science communication. You may know him from his documentary work on the sexual practices of barnacles, the evolution-creation debate, or global warming. Randy is coming out with a new book, Don't…
I've been somewhat decoupled from blogdom in general recently, as I've been busy working on the book and getting ready for FutureBaby. It's also been a useful mental health break, though, as I'm a little less worked up about stupid stuff than I was a few months ago. Every now and then, I catch the…
Why are basic scientific facts controversial in the public realm? What can scientists and their friends do to engage the public and move them past those misunderstandings? Those are the questions motivating fellow ScienceBloggers Chris Mooney and Matt Nisbet as they tour the country giving a talk…
In the aftermath of Sizzle Tuesday, Orac wrote a post posing a challenge to the science communicators: How would you deal with antivaccinationism? What "frames" would you use to combat the likes of Jenny McCarthy? In the comments on Orac's post, Matthew C. Nisbet turned up: The anti-vaccine…

We would make environmentalism more sexy as scientists, but the celebrities showed up first and got to clean the oil off all the cute animals.

There are rocks though. Thousands and thousands of rocks...

Likeability-you nailed it Randy.

That's why it won't work to wear the hair shirt and play the ascetic over seafood. Deny yourself and preach (even gently) to your friends, and the only thing that will happen is you won't get invited next time they go out to dinner.

Proud self-denial will play even worse if one of us gets a rare moment of fame and a chance to talk to the world about fish.

Happy talk about oceans is pathetic these days, but trying to sell a hair shirt to the public may be the only thing that is worse. If that's all we have to offer, nobody will be joining our crusade.

I think people differ greatly on this issue. For example, if it were completely unidentifiable as my own, I would have no problem with a picture of my naked ass being posted on the Internet. Others would be absolutely horrified by the prospect.

I think people differ greatly on this issue. For example, if it were completely unidentifiable as my own, I would have no problem with a picture of my naked ass being posted on the Internet. Others would be absolutely horrified by the prospect.