Shut Your Trap: New Rules for Salmon Farms Elicit Unhappy Response from...Salmon Farmers

Salmon farmers have to convert their open salmon pens to closed-containment systems in five years--at least that's the recommendation approved by the aquaculture committee of the British Columbia government last week. Not suprisingly, salmon farmers are outraged at the proposition.

The B.C. legislature's sustainable aquaculture committee voted 5-4 to recommend the province become the world leader in developing alternative methods to growing salmon in the ocean. Now those recommendations are voted on by the provincial legislature (likely to happen in October). If the new recommendations are passed, it would be a victory for environmental groups like the David Suzuki Foundation, which strongly oppose offshore salmon farming and the waste and sea lice they bring with them.

Tags

More like this

One of our longtime heros of Shifting Baselines is Pulitzer Prize-nominated journalist Mark Dowie. In this recent essay he takes the Bush administration to task over their plans for large scale (too large?) aquaculture. What he notes is that, "while the U.S. Congress recently passed amendments to…
I was recently interviewed for an article for the new Granville magazine here in Vancouver (I enjoyed the experience and odd coincidence that I was also born and raised in Granville, Ohio). The author, Isabelle Groc, did a great job exploring the complications of sustainable seafood in an…
This week the Vancouver Sun ran a story about the deaths of marine mammals at salmon farms, which smatter the British Columbian coast: The Living Oceans Society says that within a two-week period a Pacific white-sided dolphin, harbour porpoise and Steller sea lion got entangled and drowned in the…
Logging the Onset of The Bottleneck Years This weekly posting is brought to you courtesy of H. E. Taylor. Happy reading, I hope you enjoy this week's Global Warming news roundup skip to bottom Another week in the Ecological Crisis Information is not Knowledge...Knowledge is not WisdomOctober 23,…

But many so-called wild salmon start their lives in fish farms called hatcheries. What are they going to do about these farmed fish that get to be called wild because they live free for the last part of their lives?

Of course you're right. But at least governments and producers do not have to spend the money (or the subsidies) to catch the fish for wild salmon to eat (just for the hatcheries, which they also spend for farmed salmon). And the magnificent hundred and thousand mile migrations upstream still happen each year...

I think people differ greatly on this issue. For example, if it were completely unidentifiable as my own, I would have no problem with a picture of my naked ass being posted on the Internet. Others would be absolutely horrified by the prospect.