1. shiftingbaselines
  2. Consumption Factor: 32

Consumption Factor: 32

By jjacquet on January 2, 2008.

Jared Diamond has a great Op-Ed in the New York Times today comparing consumption between the developed and developing world. Thirty-two times. That's how many more resources we consume (the one billion people in developed countries) than the 5.5 billion people in developing nations. Gross, huh? But Diamond says giving some stuff up (and a lot of it is just nondescript stuff) shouldn't make us nervous.

Real sacrifice wouldn't be required, however, because living standards are not tightly coupled to consumption rates. Much American consumption is wasteful and contributes little or nothing to quality of life. For example, per capita oil consumption in Western Europe is about half of ours, yet Western Europe's standard of living is higher by any reasonable criterion, including life expectancy, health, infant mortality, access to medical care, financial security after retirement, vacation time, quality of public schools and support for the arts. Ask yourself whether Americans' wasteful use of gasoline contributes positively to any of those measures.

And then--and this is SO COOL--Diamond gives a shout out to global fisheries:

Other aspects of our consumption are wasteful, too. Most of the world's fisheries are still operated non-sustainably, and many have already collapsed or fallen to low yields -- even though we know how to manage them in such a way as to preserve the environment and the fish supply. If we were to operate all fisheries sustainably, we could extract fish from the oceans at maximum historical rates and carry on indefinitely.

Read Diamond's full piece here.

Tags
Losing Track

More like this

Medicaid, Medicare and real terrorism
[Another post from two years ago. Everybody is talking universal health care now. Two years ago, nada. Well, almost nada. Below is what we said then (and continue to say, now). But first this, to show the original post is still current: Americans are living longer than ever, but not as long as…
The US is one of the better off developing nations
If you make a ranked list among developed nations on how well the US is doing in health care, we are towards the top of the list. If you hold the list upside down: Americans live shorter lives than citizens of almost every other developed nation, according to a report from several US charities. The…
Our Ocean Future: The Glass Half Empty
Welcome to our blog entry for the Carnival of the Blue on World Ocean Day, wherein we contemplate the question of the ocean as a glass half-empty or a glass half-full. Together, we see our modern culture as a blind man wandering down a forking path with a divining rod, flipping a Ying-Yang coin…
What is health care like in France?
Here it comes. How dare I suggest the US could learn anything from France? By most assessments France provides the best health care in the world, with excellent life expectancy, low rates of health-care amenable disease, and again, despite providing excellent universal care, they spend less per…

It is so refreshing to hear someone examine a problem and point out positive solutions. I especailly like the idea that consuming less materially may in fact fill us more emotionally.

If we were to operate all fisheries sustainably, we could extract fish from the oceans at maximum historical rates and carry on indefinitely.

I wonder what part fish farms will actually play in the future? I have seen mixed results that seem to indicate it may not be a big answer. Of course, I hope I am wrong!
Dave Briggs :~)