Arguments about evolution, redux

An English backpacker who stabbed a Scottish traveller to death during a row about creationism and evolution was sent to jail for five years by a judge in Australia.

Alexander York, 33, from Essex, had become involved in a bitter argument over the origins of mankind and later, in the caravan park where they were staying, the row turned to violence.

Scottish backpacker Rudi Boa, 28, from Inverness, fell dying into his girlfriend’s arms after being stabbed in the chest by York in January last year.

Guess which one was the creationist?

The Scottish couple, who were staying in Tumut in the Snowy Mountains of New South Wales, picking fruit as part of a year-long round-the-world trip, had been arguing the case of evolution, while York, also fruit picking, had asserted that humans had been created as described in the Bible.

If you said the murderer, you win a prize.

(source)

Update: I guess I should read my Sciblings blogs more closely - PZ and Greg posted on the stabbing yesterday.

More like this

Yesterday, in an Australian Court, Englishman Alexander Christian York was sentenced to Five Years max for the stabbing death of Scottish biochemist Rudi Boa during an argument over evolution. The argument happened in January of Last Year. York, traveling alone, and Boa, with his girlfriend,…
They're violent, murderous bastards. Rudi Boa, a scientist, got into an argument with Alexander York, an ignorant ass, while on a backpacking trip in Australia. Boa was arguing for evolution, while York was arguing for idiocy. Later, under the influence of alcohol, York attacked, stabbed, and…
I'm sure that there are cases all over the world every day like this one that are generally ignored, but case of a creationist who killed a biomedical scientist during an argument over evolution has made a few of my fellow bloggers take notice. While it might be tempting to point at creationists…
These are extracts from stories about homicides in England found by searching Factiva for "self-defence and (burglar or robber)". No Charge Over Death Of Burglar. By Duncan Campbell Crime Correspondent. 23 January 1996 The Guardian A businessman will not be prosecuted over the…

Sadly, his best argument against evolution was in trying to settle the issue in such a barbaric manner.

On a lighter note, perhaps you'd be interested in this book. As a chemist I can't justify adding it to my collection.

http://www.biblio.com/books/105562619.html

By Chris Marks (not verified) on 15 Dec 2007 #permalink