Kyle Lewallen

Texas oilman Kyle Lewallen is building toward something, I guess. He hasn't actually made an argument yet. Ah, he was on the writing committee, and is offering their suggested revisions for the Earth and Space Science TEKS. They don't like amendments offered last time around by the Board, who didn't consult their expert writing committee before mucking with the text.

NCSE has been pushing simply to reverse those amendments, but the committee is offering revisions which might be easier for the Board to stomach.

Dunbar and Lewallen are going back and forth over the amendments to ESS TEKS 4 and TEKS 8A.

Hardy observes that these were suggested by one board member. That one person, Barbara Cargill, insists that she was just a beard for the changes offered by someone else.

Question about why biological evolution is in the ESS standards. "To exclude one from the other is inappropriate," he responds.

More like this

Bob Craig is proposing amendments to Earth and Space Science. These largely track recommendations from a panel of the ESS writers, in response to amendments offered by the Board last January. The first strikes "differing theories" and replaces it with "information about," in: 4) Earth in Space and…
An amendment by Cargill is being passed around. It changes ESS standards. Will it change the age of the earth? Oh, I'm so anxious I could plotz. Amendment is on the page listing "(4) Earth in space and time." She says it adds qualifiers. Seeks "humility and tentativeness." She wants to insert "…
Dunbar offers a new amendment to the fraught 3A, formerly the "strengths and weaknesses" language. It would now read: analyze, evaluate, and critique scientific explanations in all fields of science by using empirical evidence, logical reasoning and experimental and observational testing, by…
White wants S&W. He insists that there are credible alternatives to evolution. Thinks that random mutation can't add mutations. Do these people not read the Index of Creationist Claims? Claims evolution is a sacrosanct icon. Leo: What do you say to people who think these things belong only…