Prop. 8 stands, 18,000 marriages still legal, valid in Iowa

The California Supreme Court upheld the legality of last year's ballot initiative writing discrimination into the Constitution. No one can marry a same sex couple now, but they didn't invalidate marriages performed in the window between a previous ruling permitting same sex marriages and the amendment's passage.

This is obviously a disappointment. Proposition 8 is a travesty, and should never have passed. Indeed, it surely won't stand. More and more states are legalizing marriage equality through the legislatures, and it's increasingly uncontroversial.

The fact is, California nearly beat them all to the punch. Two successive meetings of the California legislature considered bills allowing marriage equality, with the second passing the bill. It was vetoed by Governor Schwarzenegger. Of course, now Schwarzenegger is pretending that he has no power in the matter, saying:

While I believe that one day either the people or courts will recognize gay marriage, as governor of California I will uphold the decision of the California Supreme Court. Regarding the 18,000 marriages that took place prior to Proposition 8’s passage, the court made the right decision in keeping them intact.

Yes, people voted, but so did their elected representatives, and Schwarzenegger overruled their judgment. He can't sit back and wring his hands, wishing that the outcome had been different. As so often in his governorship, he's trying to avoid responsibility, rather than taking a stand. If he opposed Proposition 8, he could have been out working to block it. If he really thought the package of budgets amendments just rejected in the popular vote were so vital, he wouldn't have been palling around in D.C. on election day, he'd have been on every radio or TV station, making a last push to shore up support. And if he didn't think those were the solution, he'd have cracked heads and gotten a few more Republicans to back something real.

Pretty soon we'll have a new Governor. Whether it's (SF Mayor) Gavin Newsom, (former governor, former Oakland Mayor, current state AG) Jerry Brown, LA Mayor Antionio Villaraigosa, or someone else, he or she will inherit a huge mess, but will have the advantage of very low expectations after the long leadership drought of the Schwarzenegger years (and the Davis years before that).

Meanwhile, we all remember Joe Hill's famous words: "Don't waste any time in mourning. Organize." Marriage equality is on hiatus from California for a while, but we'll bring it back. And as far as I can tell, same sex marriages performed elsewhere will still be legal in California.

More like this

I know I said that "all you need to know about [Martin] Cothran" is that he managed to misidentify both my employer and my profession and then repeat those easily corrected errors many times. But it turns out there's more to Cothran. Sure, he's bigoted, has an odd fascination with the word "faggot…
California is set to join Massachusetts as a hotbed for equality: Same-sex couples have a constitutional right to marry, the California Supreme Court ruled Thursday. The court’s 4-to-3 decision striking down state laws that had limited marriages to unions between a man and a woman makes California…
This morning, the California Supreme Court will announce its decision on whether or not a slim 50% majority can amend the state constitution in order to specifically deny a previously-recognized constitutional right. It will also determine the fate of the 18,000 same-sex marriages performed last…
Bruce Chapman, whose Disco. institute is still playing the greatest hits of the 1880s, writes that San Francisco is New Capital of California: as a result of the recent election the state electorate apparently decided to be governed in its top leadership almost exclusively by San Franciscans. I…

Why don't we quit referring to it as Prop 8 and start referring to it as Improp 8?!

The legislature could start by strengthening the domestic partnership to the level of civil unions or change them to that and like New York recognize outside states' same-sex marriages as if they were the ones granted before Prop 8.

The legislature could start by strengthening the domestic partnership to the level of civil unions or change them to that and like New York recognize outside states' same-sex marriages as if they were the ones granted before Prop 8.

While I agree that Prop 8 is bad, one of the problems with majority rule is that when the majority are bigots, you get bigoted laws. Ultimately, the solution is education. From what I've read, younger folk are more generally open to same-sex marriage. So progress should be made eventually.

I love this site why because I got a lot of information from this site

By Cheap Pearl (not verified) on 27 May 2009 #permalink