Did CDC ban those airline blankets?

Within 15 minutes of my 6:00 am flight from Austin to Baltimore, I knew it was going to be a long, COLD, 3-hour trip. I'd already turned off the overhhad vents to stop the frigid air from blowing on me, and contorted myself into a ball on my seat trying to stay warm. As I visualized myself lounging in the hot sun, my light slumber was interrupted by a "DING!" coming from some seat ahead of me. Two rows up, a passenger had depressed the flight attendant call button to summon the Southwest Airlines crew member.

"May I get a blanket?" the woman passenger asked.

Like me, she must have felt the airplane was doubling as a meat locker.

" No, we don't have blankets anymore. The CDC made us get rid of them."

I opened one eye to get a glimpse of the person who made that curious remark. It was indeed one of the flight attendants. Unfortunately, she has the story wrong.

During the 2009-2010 influenza season when infectious disease specialists were particularly concerned about the possiblity of an H1N1 pandemic, the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) issued "Interim Guidance for Management of Influenza-Like Illness aboard Commercial Aircraft." The document offered a variety of recommendations for controlling the spread of the virus---from discouraging fever-ridden passengers from boarding airplanes, encouraging passengers with symptoms to wear a face mask and dispose of used tissues in a plastic bag, to frequent handwashing and providing sick leave for airline crew----but the word "blanket" doesn't appear anywhere in the document.

The decision to remove the airplane blankets was Southwest Airline's call. A company spokesperson said in June 2009:

"We recently removed blankets and pillows from the aircraft in the last month or so, when the concerns about the swine flu came up. We took them out thinking we would replace them."

The Houston Chronicle's Shannon Buggs reported that the blankets and pillows never made it back into the planes' overhead bins.

"Southwest's accountants are enjoying extra cash on the balance sheet. The savings partly come from quicker cleanups of cabins that allow for faster turnarounds between flights. Plus, linens add weight to the aircraft. Their removal lightens planes' loads, which translates into slightly increased fuel efficiencies. Spread out over the entire fleet, those incremental fuel savings add up."

Buggs indicated that the flight attendants' also supported the change, with their union's spokesperson commenting:

"Those blankets have frequent-flier miles on them, to say the least. A lot of us wear gloves to handle the blankets and pillows because we notice quite a few stains on them."

On my flight, the crew member's response "CDC made us get rid of the blankets" may have simply been misinformed. Or it could be the tendency by some to blame a supposed government regulation when they have to bear news that may not be well received. As I wrote in a post last week, I've heard business owners and others invoked a "that's against OSHA regulations" in situations where there is no such OSHA rule. I guess they think it will be better tolerated than saying "our company has a policy against that."

In the case of the airline blankets, what about:

"we thought those blankets were unsanitary so we don't keep them onboard any more."

For me, the lesson is simple: throw a sweater in my carry-on bag.

More like this

[Updated 1/5/2013] [Updated 8/25/2013] The world's largest labor organization for airline flight attendants--- the Association of Flight Attendants (AFA-CWA) ---says it took four decades of work, but now its members working in airplane cabins will finally have rights and protections provided by…
What do we know about transmission of tuberculosis on an airplane? Not much, apparently. There is very little literature on it and not a single case of active TB has ever been traced to an airplane contact. On the other hand, it isn't very easy to estimate the risks. The only way you can do it is…
The liquid in question, of course, is breastmilk. As reported by the Burlington Free Press: Emily Gillette of Santa Fe, N.M., was asked to leave a flight departing from Burlington after she declined to cover her baby as she breast-fed. Gillette said she began to nurse her 22-month-old daughter as…
I'm stuck in the US East Coast ice and snow trying to get home after some science work for our nation's health agency (that is my rationale for posting this on my Sb blog). My four-hour equipment and weather delay has now turned into a canceled flight. The gate agent just announced that those of us…

As someone who takes a sweater almost everywhere, I have a suggestion. Do not put the sweater in your carry-on where it will take up space unless you have room. Instead carry it. Since it is clothing instead of a personal item, it does not incur the limits on carry-ons.

This suggestion also applies to coats. Unless you are checking bags and paying the price to check bags, save the space in your carry-on.

In these days when you better carry everything in the hand baggage, you should put on as much clothes as possible. You can take them off in the plane. I even have a vest with lots of pockets where I can carry all small but heavy little things (like my Moskva 2 camera, which is a pocketable 6x9 thingy, Soviet-made, and almost 60 years old, but still kicks ass). I spent the last New Year on a two week trip to the Dominican Republic, and managed to do it without check-in luggage.

So far the only place where the trick didn't work was in Tonga. All passengers were put on scales with their carry-on baggages, and those exceeding the total weight limit had to pay extra. You will understand the airline company's policy, when you see an average Tongan...

By Lassi Hippeläinen (not verified) on 29 Jun 2011 #permalink

It sounds like something from talk radio or perhaps a rumor that started with the staffers who listen to right wing yakkers. Not unusual. As for Southwest, they seem to live up to their hype in Texas, but not elsewhere.

I always wear my coat on the plane, even through Sky Harbor when it's 150° on the tarmac. No sense in taking-up valuble luggage space for it.

By Anonymous (not verified) on 01 Jul 2011 #permalink

Of course, the weight of all those coats and sweaters would tend to wipe out the incremental fuel savings gained by getting rid of those lightweight blankets and pillows.

By Bugtussle (not verified) on 01 Jul 2011 #permalink

Blaming the federal gov't is a tried and true tactic. Like the "OSHA fee" that so many dentists charge for every patient visit, and that patients undoubtedly think goes to OSHA.

By citizen judy (not verified) on 05 Jul 2011 #permalink