1. thescian
  2. Can we use our vocal chords to increase our virility

Can we use our vocal chords to increase our virility

By thescian on August 14, 2006.

A post at Sowmya's blog caught my attention. The point being discussed there about reciting vedas is (I'll paraphrase), Can we use our vocal chords to increase our virility? Sounds like the vedic equivalent of viagra. I can already see many readers turning red with "blasphemy" written all over their red face. Well, I stand by the question. It is correct in its essentials.

This is not a complicated scientific question to answer. IMHO, a basic knowledge of physiology and voice production can provide the broader answers to this question. Vocal chords cannot be used to increase physical virility. It can of course be used to increase your chances of mating if you are a bird, a frog or suchlike.

I have encountered the assertion that reciting poems written in sanskrit (a.k.a vedas) has physical effects. That's unscientiic gibberish. Sanskrit, contrary to what many would like you to believe, is a language with its roots in the same domain as all other languages. It evolved with the people among whom it originated. (For those who believe it is a language with divine roots, my answer is, "Great. Can I move on now? Thank you." ) Wonderfully brilliant minds that used it enriched the language with fabulous literature. It is intellectually unsatisfying and dishonest to take historical texts literally and out of their times. Besides, using poetry recital to exclude women is such a lame excuse that lacks balls.

Tags
Prime Stream

More like this

Why am I doing this Pi-Calculus Language Thing?
Since my post on datatypes for my π-calculus language, I've gotten a bunch of questions from people who (I guess) picked up on the series after the original post where I said that the idea of the series was to see if I could create a programming language based on it. The questions are all…
The suffocating Vedic flatulence
I'd love to see us stop the suffocating Vedic flatulence. Among my country men and women, there's a tendency to inflate the past beyond reasonable limits. If someone can draw a thread from Vedic literature, Vedic mathematics, Vedic astronomy, Vedic quantum mechanics and Vedic levitation it's…
I get email
All it takes is a little prompting: I write a post titled "The Bible is not a medical text", and next thing you know, someone sends me an email titled "The Vedas are a medical text". It's enough to make a fellow weep. Dear Sir, I am PhD Scholar, enrolled with Utkal University of Culture,…
A run in my stocking is not a worn out salmon: Response to Mark Liberman
I'm very please that my discussion of the "we can't ever know what a word is" Internet meme has elicited a response from Mark Liberman at Language Log. (here) Mark was very systematic in his comments, so I will be very systematic in my responses. 1. Without a careful definition of what you mean…

Nice seeing your blog here!! BTW I should've just said that 'veda recitation increases testosterone' is crap. It would've saved me a lot of time!

thank you, quitter.

Sunil, fabulous post. Thanks for doing all the heavy lifting. The link didn't get through I think. Giving it here for others: http://balancinglife.blogspot.com/2005/06/of-languages-and-tongues.html

Sowmya, the issue of sanskrit being used as a vehicle for exclusion and domination has some history - particularly within tamilnadu. I wasn't aware of the testosterone properties earlier. Quite a surprise to me, this one.