Unionizing Postdocs

This topic is discussed in a recent article in Science.

And why would postdocs want to Unionize? Here's a survey of postdoctoral fellows done by the Sigma Xi Society (and my summary).

And from my "Worst Things about Science" (also see Part II).

Why do we tolerate the low pay, the long hours, the pain? (OK it's not that bad.) The reply goes like this "Dear student/postdoc/underling, one day you'll be a great PI (principal investigator, i.e. professor) and all your hard work will have paid off. I went through this, we all have to go through this stage, so now it's your turn to go through hell." All I have to say is ... Ponzi scheme.

Currently, the only postdoc union is at the University of Connecticut Health Center. And what happened there? From the Science article:

Munirathinam Subramani, another original UHP [University Health Professionals] activist, agrees that the contract brought âbetter respect from PIsâ and raises of "close to $10,000" for some individuals. "There is no negative aspect until this moment. There was not a single incident I could give you. I donât think itâs affected any grants or relations with faculty.â In fact, he âcame out with some significant findings in my research work while I was involved in union activities. Although my boss was not so happy about my union activities, we always enjoyed doing science together.â During that same period, Subramani even found time to do some mentoring of his own, of a local high school student working in his lab, an effort that won him Glastonbury High Schoolâs best mentor award.

âI have nothing negative to say that I saw or experienced," Subramani says. Nor did his activism prevent him from receiving "three different final [job] offers including a tenure track." Before accepting his present post as an associate research scientist with faculty status in the Yale medical school, "I didnât even give a talk," he says.

The UAW has now become active in the UC system, although they do have their (anonymous) critics. The National Postdoc Association (NPA) has come out in favor of Unions. So we'll all be watching California in the next couple of months.

As CA goes ...

Tags

More like this

The lack of posts in the past 3 days was caused by our departmental retreat, that takes place on the cape (i.e. Cape Cod) in March ... we usually aim to have the retreat during a blizzard, however this year we only had mild rain. All the talking and drinking with my peers in the Cell Biology…
From the archives, in honor of Labor Day. 1 - Being scooped. There is nothing worse than working your ass off for 4 years (much of it in the coldroom) when BANG! a paper comes out making all your work useless. 2 - Begging for money. When scientists are not working, eating, sleeping or at some…
As I've written before, things are happening in California. I also learned that postdocs at University of Connecticut Healthcare Center (UCHC) joined (formed?) a union, University Health Professionals (UHP), in 2004. From the PRO/UAW site (PRO=Postdoctoral Researchers Organize): A recent article in…
Early last year when the whole Larry Summers saga broke out, I posted some data on gender and science that was floating in the public sphere. Here I've reposted some of this data. THEN I'll tell you some recent data from Harvard ... From a NY Times article Feb 22nd, 2005 Women in Physics Match Men…

I was an active opponent of unionization as a graduate student and I still believe that we were right. However, a postdoc really isn't a student. We are employees who are both getting trained and are training others. We learn and we teach and share by planning, discussing, and doing science.

Postdocs are lucky in one sense, screw up a bit (integrity issues aside) and the career isn't tanked (although that's really a maybe). However, the work hours and toll on family life isn't something that most people can really understand. In that light, someone (ahem) in our lab just drew a picture on our dry-erase board of the "evolution" associated with educational degrees:

Advanced Alien: JD
Human: MBA
Monkey: MD
Cat: MS
Mouse: BS
Cheese: PhD

Hi PostDocs and PostDoc wellwishers,
Occassionally, I crawl around the net to see what kind of postdocs activity or postdoc discussion goes on, and I found your site. Good work,keep blogging.
Hope you know me by name by now at the least. To help PostDocs learn about myraid of their issues and problems, I started the following two sites, you are all invited to the sites, hope it will give you some idea about the current affairs!!?.

Give full Respect to PostDocs, they had earned it and they deserve it!!
muni

PostDoc World, a blog
http://www.phd-postdocs.blogspot.com

The Postdoc World- a message group
21st_CenturyPostdocs_YoungScientists