NIH Grants by Age


The graph is from Are there too many PhDs? at Mendeley Blog

In the U.S., we are constantly hearing about how the country is falling behind in science. We need more scientists to fill all of those jobs we want to create. And the cure to that is to fund more PhD programs! Yet, when you ask graduate students and postdoctoral scholars what their individual experiences are, a science career is a very tough road with low pay and few career prospects. It's such a tough path that an entire PhD comic strip was born to alleviate the situation with laughter. Why then, is there such a disconnect?

HT: Razib @ Gene Expression.


More like this

Others write about it. So apparently some rant by a Physicist has been making the rounds (and it's not the first time). Lots of bloggers have commented on it. Should students be discouraged from going into science? Do we have to many PhDs? Should we help science undergrads organize their careers?…
I've written before about the problem of the Ph.D. glut, so I was pleasantly surprised (shocked, actually) to read several articles in a recent edition of Nature hitting the same themes. For those who don't think there's a Ph.D. glut, here are some data for you: Post-doc numbers shouldn't be…
In case you missed it, my Sciblings are abuzz about journalists' dismissal of Jill Biden's education. From the LA Times: Amy Sullivan, a religion writer for Time magazine, said she smiled when she heard the vice president's wife announced as Dr. Jill Biden during the national prayer service the…
I have a son who's currently a first year physics student. As you can imagine, I occasionally pass along a link or two to him pointing to stuff on the web I think he might find particularly interesting or useful. Thinking on that fact, I surmised that perhaps other science students might find…

Striking graph. How much of this trend is due to the postdoc career bottleneck vs. potentially increasing conservatism in awarding NIH grants? What would the same graph look like for trends in age distribution of all PIs? Are grants increasingly awarded to older, more established researchers?

It's the babyboomers, Lily Kim. A demographic bubble that sucks up all the $$.

Having a PhD myself, I can say this. There is simply too much emphasis placed on higher degrees. My high school friends with bachelor's alone or even many with only high school diplomas have more stable jobs than what my postdoctoral "career" has yielded. Now I teach at night at a local community college, am having the time of my life and tell all of my students to think very hard before going to graduate school for a "career" in research. Granted, the PhD vaulted me into the highest pay bracket, but that hardly makes up for the absence of health insurance for adjunct professors (I'll save that rant for another time). I wouldn't trade MY PhD for anything, but frankly, one doesn't need the credentials to understand the science or do the work. More graduate schools need to realize the value of Master's degrees instead of looking down their noses at them and treating them like consolation prizes. Assuming that every graduate student should aspire to being a PI in an academic lab is not helpful.
By the way, congratulations Alex on both the baby and the new lab.... it takes some serious brains and hard work to get where you are professionally and I have a LOT of respect for that. You and Larry provide me with a lot of ideas for bringing real science into my introductory lectures, thanks!

Naturally, the bill was enormous. Perhaps your insurance covered this mishap, perhaps not. In either case, the situation was a hassle and you were probably delayed by at least a couple of hours.