Darwin's Delay: aka I've got a few alternate theories

i-2bd58bfaaa93a3c60085fea420c53d1b-200px-Charles_Darwin_by_Julia_Margaret_Cameron.jpg

Recently, I read an interesting piece on something known as "Darwin's Delay." Briefly, this is a mystery which queried why it took 20 odd years for Darwin to take his theory of evolution from his own private musings in the late 1830's, to its publication as the Origin of Species in 1859.

Essentially, the buzz right now, is that a Darwin historian, Dr. John van Wyhe out of Cambridge, has been making a case that the reason wasn't due to Darwin fearing reaction to his work, but simply because he was,.. well... kinda busy.

Most historians argue that Darwin kept the theory secret because he was afraid of the reaction it might provoke among his peers and of damaging his reputation. At the time many scientists regarded species as fixed rather than mutable, while theologians were likely to view any theory of evolution as heretical. Psychological analyses have been carried out suggesting Darwin was frightened of ridicule and persecution and it has even been said that a dream he recorded in 1838, in which a person was hanged and came to life, was a Freudian expression of the same fears.

However, Dr van Wyhe's paper, published in the latest edition of the Notes and Records of the Royal Society, suggests that "Darwin's delay" is a myth and that he was simply busy writing more than 10 books, and sporadically hindered by ill health.

Anyway, this does make me feel a lot better about my sporadic posting on this blog, but it's an intriguing read nevertheless. As well, I can't help but think of a few other reason that could have resulted in this long delay:

* * *

OTHER POSSIBLE REASONS FOR DARWIN'S DELAY

A nasty case of tennis elbow.

TiVo

You know - had ten children.*

Actually focused on writing the screenplay. Which got shelved, then picked up, shelved again, picked up again, and then (at last check), got shelved again. The film industry is tough.

His computer, like, totally crashed.

* * *

* Seriously folks, the birthdates of his ten children pretty much matches perfectly to this 20 year delay. Could the answer just be the simple fact that Darwin was an involved father?

More like this

The Darwin Experience: The Story of the Man and his Theory of Evolution by John van Wyhe National Geographic Books It almost seems like a throwback to another age, a time when people actually read books and stuff. And National Geographic Books' The Darwin Experience: The Story of the Man and his…
I make no secret that I admire Darwin as a historical figure very much, but I recently submitted a paper for an open access journal for science teachers at secondary level named Resonance, entitled "Not Saint Darwin". I was motivated by some of the rather uncritical, unhistorical and unnecessary…
Many ideas in the history of biology get going for reasons that have to do with agendas, ideologies, and plain old bad scholarship rather than the results of research. In particular, myths regarding the motivations of historical figures. I well remember Erik Erikson's execrable attempt to…
Writing at Slate, Phil Plait has a post up about the big Ham vs. Nye debate. He gets off to a good start: Last night, science advocate Bill Nye “debated” with creationist Ken Ham, the man who runs the Creation Museum in Kentucky. I was torn about the event; I think it's important that science get…