Butterflies Dupe Ants, Trigger "Smell" Race

A new scientific paper has shown a strange, deceptive adaptation in the Maculinea butterflies of North Western Europe--an adaptation that has caused a genetic race between the butterflies and many different species of ants. The butterflies' caterpillar larvae emit a powerful smell that tricks the ants into believing that they are in fact ant larvae. The ants then...

...carry the larvae back to their secret lairs, and feed them. Just like the famed cuckoo birds, the larvae trick the ants so effectively that the ants give up on taking care of their own brood to focus exclusively on the caterpillars.

In response to this invasion, however, ants from colonies that have been "parasited" by the butterflies have evolved to have a different odor than the butterflies, and thus are able to recognize the caterpillars as frauds.

i-ff3cf25a39537054f2dd88a6283d204b-Butterfly 1.jpg

i-9d5e88a789659655f56e1c7c4fd2ede7-Butterfly 2.jpg

i-f951f6ceda0bf972ef84579bfa2d715e-Butterfly 3.jpg

In their research David Nash, Jacobus Boomsma and others from the Centre for Social Evolution (CSE) at the University of Copenhagen show that colonies of ants which developed a resistance (a different smell) and then interbred with colonies who had not been exposed to the parasites lost their resistance as the genes were diluted. Of course, they then fell victim to the Maculinea butterflies again.

The cuter brown grub is the Maculinea caterpillar

More like this

Ants are among the most successful of living things. Their nests are well-defended fortresses, coordinated through complex communication systems involving touch and chemical signals. These strongholds are stocked with food and secure from the outside world, so they make a tempting prospect for any…
In 1979, somewhere in Dartmoor, a butterfly died. That would hardly have been an exceptional event, but this individual was a Large Blue butterfly (Maculinea arion) and it was the last of its kind in the United Kingdom. Over more than a century, the Large Blue's population had been declining and…
Humans aren't the only species that have had to deal with the issue of slavery. Some species of ants also abduct the young of others, forcing them into labouring for their new masters. These slave-making ants, like Protomagnathus americanus conduct violent raids on the nests of other species,…
Although these two ants in northern Argentina look like they're ignoring each other, they are in fact doing just the opposite. This end-to-end confrontation is an intense chemical duel. What's particularly interesting about the image is the juxtaposition of two different defense systems. At left…

Once the ants start feeding the larvae and then forget about their own little guys, what happens next? Swarms of ninja butterflies then arrive, called by a top secret code radar emission by the trick larvae, to rape and pillage the unsuspecting and unprotected hoard of ants? I don't get it. This article doesn't make sense.

By Old Randy (not verified) on 06 Jan 2008 #permalink

Or do the larvae just lie there and wait until the right moment when tiny pupa-razi bust out of the cocoon and start snapping pics of ant-larvae threesomes? I still don't get it.

By Old Randy (not verified) on 06 Jan 2008 #permalink

Old Randy - How old are you? For instance, do you have teeth?