The Light Brown Controversy Moth

No one quite knows when the Light Brown Apple Moth arrived on the shores of California, but after DNA identification in 2007, it wasted no time pitting the California Department of Food and Agriculture and the populace of San Francisco against one another. Today the CDFA announced a new strategy for the eradication campaign: releasing bioengineered sterile moths to lure-in amorous males.

i-657c86b97bc0a6e4b7451ab3c066017a-light brown apple moth.jpg
Ever tried to neuter a moth? Not easy...

Indigenous to Australia, the non-descript moth breeds prolifically with an average of three broods generations per year. However, much like Paul Hogan before it, the tiny moth has spread its wings and fanned out around the globe with its ridiculous little accent. Actually, it's more likely that the eggs or larvae stowed away in cargo, but whatever their star-vehicle, they have since been identified in New Zealand, New Caledonia, the British Isles, Hawaii and now the US mainland.

Upon identifying the invasive moth, the USDA declared war. Specifically, the California Department of Food and Agriculture began an aggressive...

...spraying campaign launching hot female moth pheromones in the San Francisco and Santa Cruz areas. The idea was to confuse the male moths into thinking females were everywhere, thereby preventing them from finding a viable mate. Just what San Francisco needs, confusing sexual chemicals sprayed in the air!

Not surprisingly, many San Franciscans objected to being doused in noxious moth sex fumes. Real or imagined, over 600 adverse health effects were reported in relation to the spraying. Naysayers also pointed to the fact that no actual California crop damage had yet been reported and that Hawaii claims the moths are actually a boon, consuming invasive species but avoiding the native ones.

Australia, New Zealand and Britain feel very differently however, and report substantial crop damage annually at the mouths of the moth larvae. The CDFA also points out that the moths could threaten beloved native species like the redwood.

With San Francisco's fickle tastemakers having ruled weaponized-moth-spray-sex "uncool," the CDFA scientists are trying a new approach by releasing specially designed sterile moths. The hope is that these infertile female moths will attract the male light brown apple moths and prevent them from successfully mating with normal females. While this new method is still likely to attract critics, it seems less likely to strike fear in the hearts of Whole Foods patrons.

Fresh on the heels of our insects-as-syringes post, Zooillogix sees all sorts of applications for moth born medicine: Vaccines in third-world countries; Birth control in middle schools; etc. We envision moths as a modern day Tinker Bell, just with pixie dust that tastes like crushed Aspirin!

More like this

Bear with us on this one...it might get a little complicated: Wasps from the genus Copidosoma lay two eggs into a host egg (for example a moth or butterfly egg). One of these two eggs is male and one is female. The male and female larvae then begin multiplying--much like single celled organisms--…
Bear with us on this one...it might get a little complicated: Wasps from the genus Copidosoma lay two eggs into a host egg (for example a moth or butterfly egg). One of these two eggs is male and one is female. The male and female larvae then begin multiplying--much like single celled organisms--…
Neivamyrmex nigrescens, Arizona Army ants have a decidedly tropical reputation.  The term conjures spectacular images of swarms sweeping across remote Amazonian villages, devouring chickens, cows, and small children unlucky enough to find themselves in the path of the ants.  Of course, the…
Bruce Chapman, whose Disco. institute is still playing the greatest hits of the 1880s, writes that San Francisco is New Capital of California: as a result of the recent election the state electorate apparently decided to be governed in its top leadership almost exclusively by San Franciscans. I…

Hello to all the Google users who searched for "noxious moth sex fumes"!

the "whole foods" patrons will rightfully still be concerned about spraying over rural areas which there is plenty of in monterey and santa cruz counties. there is thing called drift. they will also not enjoy haven their neighborhoods splattered, glopped and twisted with twist ties, permethrin and other insectides through truck fogging, pole and tree painting.

By donna kuhn (not verified) on 23 Jun 2008 #permalink

"Ever tried to neuter a moth? Not easy..."

No... but it is possible.

For a real challenge try getting the little bastards to use condoms. Male moths, like most males, pretty much refuse to pay attention during the lectures. And generally compliance was poor. This wasn't helped any when the visual aids and lecture development budget was slashed because the government wouldn't fund anything but abstinence only.

Talk about your thankless jobs.

On the bright side we were eventually able to get near 100% compliance with the abstinence only curriculum from the participating male moths. After an hour-long lecture we summarily smacked each one with a swatter.