Revere over at Effect Measure has an excellent post linking together the current bird flu situation with John Snow's investigations of 19th century cholera outbreaks. It's an interesting take on the situation--check it out.
- Log in to post comments
More like this
One of the most famous stories in all of epidemiology revolves around the very birth of the science, in the midst of a London cholera outbreak in 1854. At the time, the scientific community was divided over the cause of cholera and other diseases. The majority of them accepted the miasma…
The "father" of epidemiology is a nineteenth century doctor, John Snow. He had more than one disciplinary child, since he is also considered the "father" of anesthesiology, having popularized the use of chloroform in obstetrics by using it on Queen Victoria in the 1850s. That distinction aside,…
Yesterday I gave a nod to an important epidemiologist, the late Alice Stewart. I'm old enough to have known her, but not old enough to know the most famous epidemiologist of all -- indeed sometimes called the "Father of Epidemiology" -- Dr. John Snow. Snow is also claimed as the "Father of…
Given that Haiti is suffering from the devastation of a major earthquake and a cholera epidemic, it's not surprising that voters yesterday encountered disorganized polling places where many were told their names weren't on the rolls. But there were also reports of violence and intimidation, polling…
What's the connection with bird flu?
There is no connection. Read a book about early industrial revolution and the extremely difficult conditions of the poor and anybody with a normal brain can understand that decaying organic matter and waste were certainly not the most difficult problems the poor had to handle.
19th century London cholera has nothing to do with 21st century avian flu. The avian flu pandemic is a stupid hoax invented by WHO and other officials who simply swap labels here and there to make their cases look the way they want them to look.
What? Hundred of millions of dead birds? Yeah, killed by men. One chicken infected, a hundred thousand slaughtered.
JS
--
JS: LOL. There were a lot of people with "normal brains" in the 19th century who didn't think it was as obvious as you do. I would be interested to know what you think the biggest problems of the poor were. And what did 19h century cholera in London "have to do with"? Just curious. As for your WHO et al. paranoia, what does that have to do with? Just asking someone with a normal brain, of course.
One parallel is clear.
It might have reflected a moral failing or secret sinfulness of the victim, or a moral failing in a society that allowed poor people to live in such squalor.
That really sounds familiar. Vibrio cholerae? Not when you can apply Calvinism!
Just a note for the uninitiated--jspreen is our resident germ theory denier. Heaven forbid he actually would go and read Revere's post before he spouted off on it...
Just a note for the uninitiated--jspreen is our resident germ theory denier.
I think this link is even better!
Tara: First, thanks for the post. Second, thanks for the diagnosis of JS. He/she/it/they posted the same comment on EM but I didn't bother to answer. Now I'm glad I didn't. Sorry for feeding the troll.