Having daughters makes you more left-wing (in Britain and Germany) or more right-wing (in the United States)

Sociologists Dalton Conley and Emily Rauscher claim:

Using nationally-representative data from the [1994] General Social Survey, we [Conley and Rauscher] find that female offspring induce more conservative political identification. We hypothesize that this results from the change in reproductive fitness strategy that daughters may evince.

But economists Andrew Oswald and Nattavudh Powdthavee have found the exact opposite:

We [Oswald and Powdthavee] document evidence that having daughters leads people to be more sympathetic to left-wing parties. Giving birth to sons, by contrast, seems to make people more likely to vote for a right-wing party. Our data, which are primarily from Great Britain, are longitudinal. We also report corroborative results for a German panel.

How to resolve these? See here.

More like this

Ever since I first started writing about antivaccine conspiracy theorists (but I repeat myself) back in 2005, it's always been assumed by many who combat this particularly pernicious and dangerous form of quackery that antivaccine views tend to be more predominant on the political left compared to…
In Creation/Evolution circles, the Salem Hypothesis suggests that "In any Evolution vs. Creation debate, A person who claims scientific credentials and sides with Creation will most likely have an Engineering degree." Surveys of the phenomenon suggest that it is a very real phenomenon.…
Could test tube babies be revealing some of the hidden workings of evolution? It's a definite possibility, judging from some recent reports about the balance of males and females. For several decades, evolutionary biologists have been trying to figure out the forces that set this balance. It…
Obviously the most prominent Indian American politician today is Bobby Jindal, the governor of Louisiana. But Jindal is not very representative of Indian Americans: ...Additionally, there are also industry-wide Indian American groupings including the Asian American Hotel Owners Association and the…

Some of the most left-wing Americans I know have daughters, often nothing but daughters.

If not for those pesky girls, we'd have had a revolution by now!

By Pierce R. Butler (not verified) on 06 Apr 2010 #permalink

I'm a 'merkin and have become more liberal as I've gotten older and produced three daughters. I don't know whether it's age, offspring gender, or something else that's made me identify more with the left. Not that I was ever particularly conservative.

This may have a lot to do with points of reference. I have daughters and am, by by native country's (U.S.A.) standards, left-leaning. I would, however, likely be considered moderately conservative by most Europeans. When asked, I call myself a radical centrist.

By ancientTechie (not verified) on 06 Apr 2010 #permalink

I, too, am the middle-aged eldest of a four daughter brood, and in no way consider myself right-leaning. And my parents are certainly not right-wingers. How did this happen in Deep South, USA?