Griffin replies to AAS

Via NASAwatch - NASA administrator Griffin replies to the American Astronomical Societies' Six Questions On NASA Priorities and Processes

Read it.
Interesting, tempered, with interesting conceptual holes.

1) the "mission balance" is not just different size missions, it is also different sub-fields.
If there is any desire for a long term broad space science program, then there needs to be a balance between sub-fields, not just mission classes.

2) there is serious disconnect on the "workforce crisis".
There is a very frustrating "MBA mentality" which seems to think that science expertise is fungible and can be purchased off-shelf. It isn't and it can't be - it takes 5-10 years to build expertise and a significant trained workforce (with one exception, if you can persuade everybody to drop everything and do a one-time push on something important - a la Manhattan Project).
So if you disband across a field, even for a couple of years, then you take a decade to recover.
People will stick around for a year to see if funding comes back, much more than that and you see an exodus - to finance, computing firms, plumbing etc. You permanently lose what you spent a lot of money building up.

Tags
Categories

More like this

I heard it from a man who, heard it from a man who, heard it from another... ok, it was an e-mail, but it confirmed the strange tale I had been told. NASA is about to do a Mad Max on its Science Missions. Five missions enter, one mission leaves. Literally. NASA has many houses. Within one is the…
I haven't spent much time in that den of iniquity, DC, lately but... third hand rumours percolate back to me, and if I can't sleep, neither should you a few weeks ago, a commenter said something to the effect that "NASA would do nothing until JWST was out of the way" - I thought at the time it was…
Official word out of DC - associate administrator for the Science Directorate, Dr Mary Cleave is retiring in spring 2007. This implies possible significant policy changes for space science next year, including changes in funding priorities, particularly for the smaller niche missions and sub-fields…
It was NASA proposal season last month, meant to comment on it, but was so exhausted and pissed off about the whole thing that I needed some space. A typical proposals is 15 pages of main text; including biblio, bios, associated documents and blurbs the final (electronic) package is typically 40-55…