NASA: where is our stimulus, dude?

As the Hubble servicing mission is going up, hopefully, we contemplate what on Earth is going on with NASA.

Like, why the cuts?

Well, I have no inside info on this, have not talked to anyone back east, so I'm guessing:

first, NASA is just not that much of a priority - too small, and the science stimulus is fairly well covered with NSF and DoE, not to mention NIH and NOAA;

secondly, the Obama transition team did not get what it needed from top levels of NASA, and this did not help expedite things;

thirdly, Obama did well initially getting senior appointees confirmed, but then hit a rash of problems and NASA administrator was not in the pipeline. Since then, by all accounts, some senior senators from FL and TX are holding things up - they want space cadets who will keep the money flowing to Exploration - building hardware to replace the shuttle and keeping JSC and KSC busy.
This is problematic, because major long term decisions about NASA's future need to be made Real Soon Now - like wtf to do with manned spaceflight and how - the shuttle is committed to retirement, and the Constellation Spam Cans are not ready and not looking all that good.

fourthly, Earth Science got tossed a stimulus bone, but didn't get a serious long term boost, their funding is placeholder level and actually steps back after the acceleration from the stimulus. The other Science units are being cut, in the plan, but that is basically because major cost "bumps" are being crossed over - like JWST peak and HST refurbishment bump in Astrophysics - and nothing new is being authorized.
Nothing new is being authorized because there is no one pushing for it, and little billion dollar, or two, initiatives like IXO or LISA etc are below the threshold of sensitivity for the White House.
The proximate cause here is lack of administrator - yes, White House could set policy, but a) they're kind busy, and b) you don't set policy and then bring a new top person... duh!

So, NASA is in deep doo-doo.
There is a new commission, and with Augustine chairing I'm sure it will make strong statements.
NASA can, and ought to be a major part of the science stimulus. It can also provide shovel ready projects, especially if some move is made to actually provide funding for launch technology that works.
But, NASA needs to have a goal - a real, serious, doable, funded, long term goal - that is interesting, inspiring, drives technology development, good engineering, furthers national goals,
and does science.

But that requires leadership, and that requires an administrator.

More like this

NASA 2011 budget is out, and with it the new 5 year plan. It is drastic, bit more so than I expected. Short version: Constellation is dead, Dead, DEAD! Ares I, Ares V and Orion are shut down. ~ $10 billion thrown away, again, with nothing to show for it, again. More money, I'll backfill the…
Let's say you wanted to kill NASA. You couldn't just blink it out of existence I Dream Of Jeannie style, but you might be able to strangle it to death in bureaucracy. How might you do it? For starters, you might completely scrap any attempt to return humans to the moon. You might completely…
It was NASA proposal season last month, meant to comment on it, but was so exhausted and pissed off about the whole thing that I needed some space. A typical proposals is 15 pages of main text; including biblio, bios, associated documents and blurbs the final (electronic) package is typically 40-55…
NASA Administrator Charles Bolden addressed a packed room filled with anxious astronomers at lunch today. It was interesting, both in what he said and in what was omitted. I'll get to actual science at the AAS Real Soon Now , so more politics in the meantime. Bolden's talk was primarily a scripted…

A commitment to a complete exploration of the Solar System. The first stage is to put high-quality exploration robots in orbit of every major object inside the orbit of Neptune, and on the surface of every world with a surface our robots can explore. And every robot downloads images to a 24-hour cable channel, and data to a publicly accessible webpage. This includes a Kuiper-belt probe that has a camera 'always' focused on Earth.....

By oscar zoalaster (not verified) on 11 May 2009 #permalink